3 ms·
Why would they still use old codec when there are modern and free ones like Opus?
by shmerl 10y ago
Why would they still use old codec when there are modern and free ones like Opus?
- jackvalentine 10y agoFrom the site: Developers When would I need to decode AC-3? Playing most live TV content Playing most recorded TV content Playing many videos from DVD Playing many videos from Blu-Ray Playing videos recorded by some digital camcorders Playing some online streaming content offered in 5.1 surround sound When would I need to encode AC-3? Hopefully never! In practice, there are a few cases: Encoding surround sound audio for some legacy TVs and devices that only support AC-3 for surround. Modern devices can decode other multichannel formats such as AAC, DTS, and Opus. Encoding surround sound audio to be sent to a legacy AV receiver using an optical cable (S/PDIF). Modern AV receivers can accept other formats over HDMI, including multichannel PCM. Is AC-3 any good? Should I use it for new stuff? No, of course not. AC-3 is over 25 years old and horribly inefficient.
- Veratyr 10y agoAC-3 is a part of many current standards (i.e. is a hard requirement) and has wide hardware support. Opus lacks both hardware and software support on many platforms (notably iOS) and ultimately, doesn't perform that much better than existing, supported codecs like AAC, which already have to be licensed for other reasons. I love Opus and it's used by some big players like YouTube but ultimately I don't see it taking the place of MP3/AAC for music or AC-3/DTS for premium video anytime soon.
- shmerl 10y agoAAC is patent encumbered, so it's not a suitable option for replacing standards. That's what I'm talking about. Standards aren't supposed to be forever stuck with old tech. I see no reason why Opus couldn't be part of more standards (it's already part of WebRTC), besides of course Apple which can't stand free codecs.