5 ms·

I would tend to agree. This quote from the epilogue drove home that the author doesn't think that's reasonable though: > However, I still do not believe that i

by boulos 10y ago

I would tend to agree. This quote from the epilogue drove home that the author doesn't think that's reasonable though: > However, I still do not believe that if one out of three availability zones in a region is practically offline that is reasonable to report that region as healthy. I can agree that it should be easier to see and understand that there are zonal issues, but I can't agree that the region was unhealthy. Now if 2 out of 3 zones were down, that's a real concern (you can't run a highly-available service anymore). Said another way: what if there were 20 zones in the region and only one were down? Disclosure: I work on Google Cloud.

SomeStupidPoint 10y ago
I've had this question for a while: do we know there are only 2-3 zones per region, or might there be 10-20 and, for example, my zone 'a' is your zone 'c', and neither of us has access to the other's zone 'b' (yours too old/loaded to be assigned to me; mine too new for you)?
- jedberg 10y ago
  Sort of. The "zones" are just logical constructs. They can be one building or many tied together with fat fiber links. And you're right that my "A" and your "A" may be different. They are randomly assigned the first time you launch a resource. Also, there are decommissioned zones that new accounts can't see but old ones can if they've ever launched something there before (if they haven't then that zone letter will be reassigned to a new zone with no one the wiser). Typically they won't let you launch new things in that zone, so it's in your bet interest to move out of it, lest your resources get out of balance. Edit: Oh and old accounts can always see new zones as far as I know. They just show up as new letters. But it's rare that they add new zones -- usually they just make old zones bigger.
  - boulos 10y ago
    Right. In some set of slides, James Hamilton has certainly said at least how many buildings there are for us-east-1 and it's a lot more than the up to four zones people see (IIRC, >26). Most customers will never notice the randomization of building => zone, but every once in a while you rely on a vendor like MongoLabs and its important you both are speaking about the same us-east1-b. The AWS folks let you tie yourself together in case you have multiple projects that need identical mappings.
    - jedberg 10y ago
      Us-east actually has five zone, but one of them was decommissioned many years ago, so unless your account is very old, you can only see four. As far as I know, that's the only zone that's ever been fully decommissioned.

by boulos 10y ago

SomeStupidPoint 10y ago

I've had this question for a while: do we know there are only 2-3 zones per region, or might there be 10-20 and, for example, my zone 'a' is your zone 'c', and neither of us has access to the other's zone 'b' (yours too old/loaded to be assigned to me; mine too new for you)?

jedberg 10y ago
Sort of. The "zones" are just logical constructs. They can be one building or many tied together with fat fiber links. And you're right that my "A" and your "A" may be different. They are randomly assigned the first time you launch a resource. Also, there are decommissioned zones that new accounts can't see but old ones can if they've ever launched something there before (if they haven't then that zone letter will be reassigned to a new zone with no one the wiser). Typically they won't let you launch new things in that zone, so it's in your bet interest to move out of it, lest your resources get out of balance. Edit: Oh and old accounts can always see new zones as far as I know. They just show up as new letters. But it's rare that they add new zones -- usually they just make old zones bigger.
- boulos 10y ago
  Right. In some set of slides, James Hamilton has certainly said at least how many buildings there are for us-east-1 and it's a lot more than the up to four zones people see (IIRC, >26). Most customers will never notice the randomization of building => zone, but every once in a while you rely on a vendor like MongoLabs and its important you both are speaking about the same us-east1-b. The AWS folks let you tie yourself together in case you have multiple projects that need identical mappings.
  - jedberg 10y ago
    Us-east actually has five zone, but one of them was decommissioned many years ago, so unless your account is very old, you can only see four. As far as I know, that's the only zone that's ever been fully decommissioned.