5 ms·
While planned obsolescence is probably a factor I'd also consider the desire for more complicated features, efficiency requirements, and high (upfront) price se
by emodendroket 10y ago
While planned obsolescence is probably a factor I'd also consider the desire for more complicated features, efficiency requirements, and high (upfront) price sensitivity on the part of consumers. To the last point in particular I think you will find that a refrigerator was way more expensive in real dollars in 1950.
- orless 10y agoI think many people won't mind paying a higher price for a longer-lasting product. But there's just no way to know it will really be longer-lasting.
- mikeash 10y agoIf a manufacturer is confident that their product will last, they can convey this to the buyer by providing a really good warranty.
- toast0 10y agoA really long warranty only helps if the company remains solvent. I would be happier with something the manufacturer was confident was serviceable. Control boards that approach the cost of a high end smartphone are unreasonable, but also common.
- no_wizard 10y agoI always had this dream of starting a company where my disruption to whatever industry, say home appliances, or cars, isn't that I'm doing something new, per say, its that I'm engineering everything the company would sell with DIY easy access fixes in mind, and actually publish (and ship with the product) the repair manual so people can just order the parts (with some margin, nothing crazy i'd think) and be on their way. Sell it to the self reliant, tinkers, and generally just people who hate to pay the high cost of repairs on things. I wonder, truly, if this would be successful. I have no way of even wrapping my head around how to get something like that off the ground. I think if someone designed and shipped a car, for instance, that was completely serviceable by the owner and designed with that in mind first and for most, you could easily disrupt the car market for a very broad amount of people today.
- sokoloff 10y agoMany cars are largely DIY-friendly already. I do all of the work on our cars except tires, exhaust, bodywork/paint, and manufacturer recalls. In the last 15 years, I can only recall one time a car went into a shop for a reason other than the above and that was an independent shop where I was too busy to deal with the job. That's across a Mercedes, a Jeep, a Honda CR-V, and Alfa Romeo, and some classic Mustangs. There are a few marques that are DIY-unfriendly (hello, BMW), but most cars can be effectively DIY maintained. A DIY-friendly car would not be as disruptive as perhaps you think.
- axaxs 10y agoTrue, but even this trend is slowly changing sadly. Remember when fuel filters used to be inline? Sure, it's still DIY, but it's now no longer safe or easy to change them yourself without relatively expensive equipment, and a prayer you don't break a bolt or strap. Ever tried to change a battery on the reintroduced Beetle? As time goes on, drive by wire becomes more prevalent, etc...cars are slowly becoming harder to repair for the shadetree mechanic. Even the things that are still possible have become, in general, more cumbersome.
- no_wizard 10y agoPerhaps. However I don't think they were built in mind for maximum owner repairability. I suspect they wouldn't be fighting the right to repair so hard otherwise
- emodendroket 10y agoMost people never open up their cars though.
- toast0 10y agoI don't think you need to make it easy enough for an average person, but easy enough for a repair person to do repairs in about 30 minutes, so the service call is kind of reasonable. Combine that with trying to keep parts compatible over years and you would develop a following.
- Jill_the_Pill 10y agoWe cleaned up by buying the extended warranty on our dreadful dishwasher. For a modest charge upfront, Sears sent out technicians 5 or 6 times, replaced the electronic control panel, a valve, and the entire washer motor. It took months and months of angry phone calls, but the damned thing works now.
- orless 10y agoYou can purchase an additional warranty for decent money. Handling repairs is still a huge mess and burden - even if you're not paying for them. I read a couple of "four weeks without refrigerator" horror stories. That they happend on the warranty time did not make them any better. I don't want a good warranty, I want a well working equipment.
- emodendroket 10y agoThose are pretty much worthless. They usually exclude all the most common reasons the thing would break.
- mikeash 10y agoA good warranty from the manufacturer is different, since it incentivizes them to make a product they don't have to repair in the first place. Once you're paying for a warranty, that goes out the window.
- snotrockets 10y agoI'm willing to bet manufacturers actually went and did market research, and found out the opposite. As if there was a market demand, they would have build and market such products.
- no_wizard 10y agoThats always the assumption isn't it? That they already did the research and found no demand for x. I think if I have learned anything from Silicon Valley though its this: Never assume that these assumptions are categorically true, or that they were undertaken with due diligence. Perhaps it is true, and there is not enough interest in this to justify it happening. What if, though, they didn't do the market research properly? Or steadfastly, it actually didn't happen at all?
- orless 10y agoI don't believe this. In Germany, "built-in" home apliances are standard for a modern kitchen. Replacing a built-in refrigerator if it failed would probably cost around 400-600€ (only replacement costs, not talking about the price of the refrigerator).
- wodenokoto 10y agoAnd this is a very interesting point. How good is a similarly priced 2017 fridge compared to a 1950's when price is measured in real dollars.
- philipkglass 10y agoPretty damn good. You can still buy refrigerators built like a tank, intended for commercial environments, if you're willing to spend 4 figures. http://www.thepeoplehistory.com/50selectrical.html http://www.thepeoplehistory.com/50selectrical.html https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=329&year1=1952&year2=2017 https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=329&year1=1952... That household refrigerator that was $329 in 1952? $3024 in 2017 dollars.
- rimliu 10y agoAnd you will save a lot on heating. People forget that old tech is not known for being efficient be it electric appliances or cars.
- someone13 10y agoI wasn't able to find anything about a fridge, but some searching found a Sears catalog from 1959: http://www.aei.org/publication/appliance-shopping-1959-vs-2012/ http://www.aei.org/publication/appliance-shopping-1959-vs-20... From that page, it looks like the price of the washer, adjusted for inflation to 2016, is $1756.12. A comparable washer today, from Sears, appears to be somewhere in the $400 - $600 range, or about 30% as much as it used to cost. Data for today's washers: http://www.sears.com/appliances-washers-top-load-washers/b-1101278?Brand=Kenmore&filterList=Brand http://www.sears.com/appliances-washers-top-load-washers/b-1...
- CydeWeys 10y agoI'm from the US, bought some appliances a few years ago, and can confirm that $500 is about what you would expect to pay for a decent washer or dryer.
- 10y ago
- shmageggy 10y agoI agree and think that this article needs an inflation-adjusted comparison of the cost of different models so we can see how much of the decline might be caused by a race to the bottom in terms of price.
- jasonkostempski 10y agoOMG, the "features". My stove is relatively simple except for 1 part, the one that sets the oven temperature (and the time, but who the hell needs a third clock in their kitchen). That part is a 300 dollar, proprietary circuit board. Of course it's the first thing to go. I'm sure the board doesn't cost the maker anywhere near $300 but I'm sure it's a lot more than an industry standard knob. If they want to cut a few bucks off the price, there's a good place to start. Put a standard knob only stove on the showroom floor and it might not be the first appliance everyone purchases but it will the be second of anyone that realizes how stupid it is to have a computer where single function piece of hardware belongs.
- emodendroket 10y agoI don't know about that particular example, but refrigerators with ice makers are an obvious case of people buying appliances way more likely to break down.
- sokoloff 10y agoYes, but I replaced my ice maker for $36 and about 30 minutes of my time (10 minutes to figure out what to order; 20 minutes to put it in). https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002GZND6U https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002GZND6U
- mark-r 10y agoIn my case it wasn't the ice maker itself, but the plumbing leading up to it within the refrigerator. I finally ended up turning off the water supply after my DIY repair broke a second time.
- emodendroket 10y agoYou can save a lot of money on almost anything if you're willing to get your hands dirty and do the work yourself. I don't think it invalidates the argument.
- 10y ago
- Nition 10y agoDo many people actually have a "desire for more features" or are most features just being crammed in in a bid to differentiate refrigerator A from refrigerator B? Personally I usually perfer the least features possible mainly because more features = more stuff to break.
- emodendroket 10y agoHN users are not typical users of technology.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]