3 ms·
>"The need for state-financed housing is per definition a failure to leverage natural market forces and points to regulations being the culprit when investment
by bogomipz 10y ago
>"The need for state-financed housing is per definition a failure to leverage natural market forces and points to regulations being the culprit when investment conditions are better than ever at the same time."
And what do you call it when a city becomes a place that only the wealthy can afford to live in? There are so many people that contribute and make a city function who are not even remotely middle class. Where do they live? Isn't that also a failure? Real-estate in desirable cities is increasingly being used to stash cash[1][2], and there are no shortage of developers who are developing property specifically to attract these types of "tenants." So no simply relying on "natural market forces"is not really an inclusionary solution.
[1]https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/25/planners-must-take-back-control-of-london https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/25/planne...
[2]http://nymag.com/news/features/foreigners-hiding-money-new-york-real-estate-2014-6/ http://nymag.com/news/features/foreigners-hiding-money-new-y...
- tannhaeuser 10y agoIf there are indeed buildings being constructed for the sole purpose to "stash cash" as you say, then the law against misuse of real estate property ("Gesetz gegen Zweckentfremdung") can and should be applied. However, it doubt that this is the case in significant quantities. My argument is a principled one: the city/state/fed should strive to let the market sort it out. That sounds neo-lib, but should be easy to achieve in times of lack of alternate investment possibilities. And while they're at it, they should make it so that investment in housing becomes a good investment opportunity for the middle class, helping with the demographic problems before us. Proposing the state should invest in housing is really just the civil society declaring bankruptcy, and leads to corrupt and unsustainable structures, as happened in the 1970s in Germany (or worse, go ask women of the former east block what they had to do to get housing). The problems (if they are real) are entirely the consequence of decades of misguided policies in construction and housing/renting laws. And also a consequence of lack of sustainable investment opportunities (ECB "QE" and negative interest rates) so people are turning to real estate.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"If there are indeed buildings being constructed for the sole purpose to "stash cash" as you say, then the law against misuse of real estate property" I wasn't speaking about Berlin specifically for that comment only that its happening in many places in the world - San Francisco, New York, London. I linked to two articles describing it different cities. So the "market will sort itself out" neo-lib doctrine you mentioned has largely failed working class and indeed middle class which are the majority compared to the wealthy.
- tannhaeuser 10y agoOk, because there are cases of real estate in NYC, SF, and London being bought to merely keep money from loosing value you conclude that capitalism has failed? The reason for this real estate bubble (money loosing value) being the ECB's and the Fed's inflationary policies and low interest rates (hence a consequence of state action)? And as a remedy you propose the state or city should buy real estate to keep housing affordable (rather than changing regulations)? So that some pseudo hipsters in Berlin's fashion quarters can keep living on social welfare (ok I'm taking that one back :) but I can tell you the taxpayers of Southern Germany, Hesse, Hamburg (and Saxony I believe) aren't amused to finance Berlin decadence [1]. I can only appeal to your computer science skills to analyze the situation rationally, rather than buying into social-romantic nonsense. [1]: since over half the residents of Berlin have their hands in the pocket of the state in one form or another, the strategy of the Senate of Berlin seems to be to "buy" their electorate with money they get from other German countries, when actually Berlin rents are much lower than in all other big German cities
- bogomipz 10y ago>"Ok, because there are cases of real estate in NYC, SF, and London being bought to merely keep money from loosing value you conclude that capitalism has failed?" Nice try, nowhere did I even remotely find fault with capitalism. Capitalism and a urban planning are two completely orthogonal concepts. You seem to be conflating the two an maligning a vote for some kind of housing policy as a vote against capitalism which is just ridiculous. They are not mutually exclusive. >"The reason for this real estate bubble (money loosing value) being the ECB's and the Fed's inflationary policies" And try to remember why central banks had to loosen the money supply. Because in 2008 the global financial system was brought to its knees by banks who believed that "the market will look after itself." And who bailed those institutions out? The taxpayers did what amounted into a systems of "privatize the rewards and socialize the risks." Typical neo-liberal bullshit hypocrisy, you have no problem accusing everyone else of "social-romantic nonsense" though. >"I can only appeal to your computer science skills to analyze the situation rationally" Spoken like a true technocrat, your'e right there's probably a good formula to explain the problem away. >"So that some pseudo hipsters in Berlin's fashion quarters can keep living on social welfare" So you have just reduced a multi-ethnic city with a population of 3 million people to a single narrow demographic. You are obviously trolling.
- Arizhel 10y ago>And what do you call it when a city becomes a place that only the wealthy can afford to live in? There are so many people that contribute and make a city function who are not even remotely middle class. Where do they live? I'm not sure how this is a problem. Shouldn't it be self-limiting? You're absolutely right: you need lots of people in a city to make it function who aren't high earners: janitors, retail workers, cab/bus drivers, etc. So what happens when a city becomes so expensive these people can't live there? For a while, they live farther away and commute, but at some point even that won't be viable. What then? Well, that seems like it'll be a big problem for the wealthy inhabitants of the city to solve, right? Why is it our concern? Those wealthy people are the ones who created the problem, and also the ones with the most resources to devote to fixing it. The rest of us are struggling to make ends meet and pay the exorbitant rents that are the result of these wealthy people; we certainly don't have time or money to deal with the problems they've brought on themselves. So if I'm missing something critical here, someone please point it out to me because I'm not utterly convinced of the correctness of my argument. I can't think of any historical examples of places where rich people priced all the service workers out of an area completely; I think this is a modern phenomenon. But it does seem that this should be one area where "the free market!!" really should work, in a way, though it might result in a bunch of wealth people really losing their shirts in the real estate market (which is fine with me; lots of people, including non-wealthy people, in 2008 learned that lesson the hard way, that real estate does not always hold its value; I'm especially not concerned about a bunch of wealthy foreigners losing their investments).