8 ms·
This type of regulation should be the province of HOAs, which have covenants that home owners agree to when buying their homes. It shouldn't be part of state la
by valuearb 10y ago
This type of regulation should be the province of HOAs, which have covenants that home owners agree to when buying their homes. It shouldn't be part of state law, and this one sounds particularly over-reaching. Basic property rights should dictate that "nuisance" be clearly defined in a very limited way.
And she has an entire acre, at least 4x larger than the typical lot size. At what size does her property become a "farm"?
I live in Arizona and have a lawn. It's expensive to upkeep and requires a ton of water. Many homes in my neighborhood have "natural" landscaping, basically rocks and cactus. I would too if I didn't have kids and a big dog. Natural is much more environmentally sound, and should be encouraged, not fined.
- IslaDeEncanta 10y agoAn acre is not a farm.
- rickboyce 10y agoIn parts of the world and acre certainly could be a very productive farm. An example in North America - "With only 1½ acres cultivated in permanent beds, the farm grosses more than 100 000$ per acre with operating margins of about 60 per cent, enough to financially sustain his family." http://www.themarketgardener.com/ http://www.themarketgardener.com/
- dsp1234 10y agoYou missed the line right above that: "an internationally recognized 10-acre micro-farm" Even 10 acres is considered "micro". Also, that's 1.5 acres of cultivated permanent beds on 10 acres. For a 1 acre farm, where are the homestead, barns, equipment(tractors, tillers, etc), animals, etc located? All of that takes up space, which can't be used for growing. You need more than a single acre to actually have an acre of growing area.
- randomdata 10y agoAs a grain farmer, one of the farms I work is only 3 acres. The answer to your question is simple: You keep them at another farm.
- DoodleBuggy 10y agoHOAs are the height of absurdity pertaining to land ownership, I will never understand why someone would volunteer to pay a monthly fee (basically a tax) to have a group of bozos tell you what you can and can't do with your own property. If the rules imposed by even a mild HOA were put in place by a local government there would be protests 24/7.
- _red 10y agoYou don't have to spend too much time wondering, since its prima facia self-evident. HOA's exist because they work out financially better than the alternatives. HOA's may not be for you, but for those that like higher property values, they are an acceptable trade-off.
- Overtonwindow 10y agoDo they really? That's the line I kept hearing when I was searching for my home but it seemed they were overly inflated, and buyers were drifting away from the silly harassment and pain of HOAs. Id say the evidence is clear: if you want to truly own your home, don't buy in an HOA. If you want others to make decisions for you, dictate how your home will look, and monitor you like a police force, then choose an HOA.
- _red 10y ago"if you want to truly own your home" Property tax? I'm not here to extoll the joys of paying and dealing with an HOA, they can be a hassle - I know it. However, consider the alternatives: Move out to unincorporated land, build your 5 acre dream home, swimming pools, tennis courts, etc. Watch as a dump and trailer park open next door...consider what your options are.
- Overtonwindow 10y agoProperty tax is nothing more than the government exerting control over your home. You'll never truly own your home with a property tax, point taken. You appeared to argue in favor of HOAs with tired lines of financial stability, with no evidence. Anyone or anything that has the power to take away your property and home is, IMHO, a mortal threat that should be removed.
- mikestew 10y agoAt what size does her property become a "farm"? Even under the loosest definitions of the word "farm", she would need a few multiples of her current acreage to qualify. An acre means you can have a large garden.
- randomdata 10y ago> At what size does her property become a "farm"? When it is zoned for agriculture.
- BeetleB 10y ago>This type of regulation should be the province of HOAs, which have covenants that home owners agree to when buying their homes. While we both agree with the problem this person is having, I'm the opposite of you with regards to your statement. HOAs can have a lot more power with a lot less oversight. If one is going to have these kinds of rules, they should be in the city/state rules or not at all. The "agree to when buying their homes" is a faulty way of looking at it. You also agree to laws of the city/state you live in. No one is preventing you from leaving if you don't like it.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoAt what size does her property become a "farm"? Size doesn't have much to do with it, and neither does a barn in any way: It more matters on zoning and location. Had a friend looking for a place with space for horses: Even a horse barn didn't mean she could keep them there. Same for my parents when they bought a hobby farm. One seemed perfect - 10+ acres, but the HOA where the house and barn sat didn't allow for the farm animals.