4 ms·
If you ever wondered what people meant by out of touch "ivory tower" academics, just read this post. Just imagine telling a client, "sorry I don't open Google
by paulcole 10y ago
If you ever wondered what people meant by out of touch "ivory tower" academics, just read this post.
Just imagine telling a client, "sorry I don't open Google Docs on principle. Life is too short and too precious."
- kartan 10y ago> If you ever wondered what people meant by out of touch "ivory tower" academics, just read this post. Did you read this: "I’ll continue to devote a huge fraction of my waking hours to fielding questions from all sorts of people on the Internet, and I’ll do it cheerfully and free of charge." The guy is doing more than most, is it so much to ask people to be polite and make things easy when asking for help?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt depends on your market position. If you're a successful company, you get to tell clients what way to send stuff in. BTW. I don't see it as being "out of touch". I see it as a gentle reminder of how we're all wasting each other's time building stuff that requires creation of accounts for no real reasons (except sales tricks).
- skywhopper 10y agoActually he said explicitly that he would open Google Docs. And 90% of the world has a Google account already. What he doesn't want to do is waste 20-30 minutes to create an account and log into a new system every time someone wants feedback on something.
- laumars 10y agoYou say that but if one looks at your example at face value then you would be surprised how often things like that do happen. I had one supplier threaten to cancel business relations with us if we didn't send through customer details (related to the product they were supplying) on an excel spreadsheet via email. It took quite some negotiation to agree a secure compromise. That's just the most recent example but I've had to deal with countless insane demands from suppliers like this over the course of my career. In several cases being borerline to saying "if you don't want our business then there's plenty of other suppliers that do". However by far the most annoying one I've had, and one that used to be common place 5 years ago in the UK, was recruitment agencies refusing to accept CVs in PDF form. They would accept a Microsoft Word document or RTF. Some even accepted plain text files. But a PDF was point blank refused even in tech-agencies. This used to be a real pain for myself, a Linux developer and administrator who didn't run Windows so couldnt guarantee what OpenOffice would spit out when exporting to .DOC. I ended up having to use a spare work machine and thankfully had a very forgiving boss.
- gbuk2013 10y agoIt's been nearly 10 years since I've had to deal with recruiters but I remember asking about DOC requirement and basically it was because they edited my CV before passing it onto the client (particularly to cut out any personal information so that the client could not contact me directly). RTF was easy enough the generate though, so it wasn't a big deal for me.
- tomjen3 10y agoWhen they insist on a doc document it is because they want to edit it, which means they are about to screw you over.
- laumars 10y agoI guessed that much myself to be honest :). However it has always been trivially easy to copy and paste content from a PDF so their restriction didn't make much sense to me even with that point in mind. And with the added issue that every tech recruiter I approached enforcing the same policy, it made it impossible to shop around for recruitment agencies that would honour my CV. Thankfully I've not had the same issues when job hunting again recently. At least not thus far.
- quickben 10y agoNo. Imagine you telling your client 3 times a day to create a different account with different workflow. Did you even read the article and its main point?
- LoSboccacc 10y agoI think many just skipped the article and missed the whole point by miles. Just look at that page comments, over and over again people suggesting a password manager. Like, that's not the point! That's barely tangential, and not even mentioned anywhere as 'the issue'! It's about mandatory account creation! How would a password manager even solve that! /rant
- Veen 10y agoThis is an academic talking about work he's doing for free to help other academics and students. In order to help these people, he's required to engage in shadow work that benefits neither him nor the people he's trying to help. I applaud the stand he's taking. Rent-seeking publishers are not only extracting value without providing much to justify their slice of the pie, they're doing it in such a way as to put an additional burden on everyone else. If I had a client who forced me to spend twenty minutes creating an account and logging into a service that provided a hostile user experience, I'd try to educate them about better alternatives, and if they weren't amenable to that, I'd charge them for the wasted time.
- mrweasel 10y agoOn the other hand, I previously had a job where I was almost always the customer. As a B2C website, we ensured that customers wouldn't have to login, they could, but they surely didn't need to if they didn't want to. Anyway, as one of the developers, every third party was pretty much always someone who wanted our money when they wanted to talk to me. That put me in a position to dictate pretty much everything, be it the company policy on a maximum of one month legal binding on any contract, or how I wanted to be contacted. After a few years of setting 15 minutes aside as prep for Skype calls and 30 minutes for Hangout call or any "enterprise" group chat thing, I started to dictate that anyone who wanted to talk to me, had to call me on my desk phone or write an email. If you didn't like it, to bad, you have competitors that will call a normal phone number. In my current job we sadly accept that customers want to use Skype, but you have to be pretty a pretty big customer, otherwise it's phone, email or an in-person meeting. We do tell customers that we prefer email, or actually that we NEED them to write us an email to have an audit trail. Putting stuff in a Google Doc isn't helpful either, we still require you to send an email. I understand that if you're a one person shop, then you can't be picky, but maybe you should. For most of us, requiring a phone call or an email is very much doable.
- exolymph 10y agoI'm a journalist, and I'm going to adopt this approach in dealing with PR people. Thankfully they're already used to it.
- bradleyjg 10y agoThese aren't clients. An analogy: Many in the tech industry are happy to offer advice to random people at the start of their careers. But the onus is on the person looking for advice to make it convenient for other person. If you received an email that said someone was looking for advice on some tech topic you were familiar with, but in order to see the details of the request and respond you have to create an account and log on to this unfamiliar website, how would you respond? I'd delete it and move on with my life. I'm happy to help, but I'm not a circus animal and I'm not going to jump through hoops for free on behalf of random people that I don't know.