3 ms·
The only way left to fight gentrification is, I am afraid to say, something between massive civil disobedience and outright violence. The alternative to fighti
by mschuster91 10y ago
The only way left to fight gentrification is, I am afraid to say, something between massive civil disobedience and outright violence.
The alternative to fighting - chilling in our sofas and doing nothing - is waking up one day in a city without teachers, cleaning/water/sewer personnel, supermarket staff and, funny enough, police. I just picked these examples as these people are already living near or below poverty line after paying rent and are vital to a healthy city.
And: it's not just Berlin that suffers from gentrification, e.g. Hamburg and Munich are falling victim to it. We as people can no longer trust the state (or the police) to serve our interest - both serve the interests of the ultra-rich investors only. Just look at London what awaits societies which do not fight with any means neccessary.
- hungrygs 10y agoFighting gentrification is stupid. Cities with growing populations need new housing supply and the market will put resources (to build) where it meets consumer demand. Unjustifiable barriers to new housing supply will only make prices go up even faster, and for crappier quality housing, too.
- mschuster91 10y agoLOL. The "free market" always goes for building ever more luxury apartments for the rich. Housing is a human right and needs to be regulated as hell, otherwise you end up like London.
- saint_fiasco 10y agoNot saying the market is infallible, but it's often smarter than you and I. When the Invisible Hand builds luxury apartments, it is indeed for the rich, because if the rich don't get the luxury apartments they want, they will settle for middle-class apartments at good locations. Since they are rich, they can outbid all the middle-class people, and only rich people will be able to live at places that used to house middle-class folk. That's what gentrification means.
- Arizhel 10y ago>The only way left to fight gentrification is, I am afraid to say, something between massive civil disobedience and outright violence. Or you could just move someplace cheaper instead of resorting to this stuff. >The alternative to fighting - chilling in our sofas and doing nothing - is waking up one day in a city without teachers, cleaning/water/sewer personnel, supermarket staff and, funny enough, police And why exactly is this a problem? Every time I ask it in a discussion like this, no one has an answer. So what if there's no retail workers, teachers, or police? Then the problem will naturally correct itself, no? A city will eventually collapse and fail without these services, and then the real estate prices will rapidly fall to affordable prices, allowing these people to return. Meanwhile, a bunch of rich landowners will lose their shirts, which is a good thing. >We as people can no longer trust the state (or the police) to serve our interest - both serve the interests of the ultra-rich investors only. You as people need to move out of these unaffordable places and go someplace more affordable. You're part of the problem. You demand space in this limited market, along with everyone else, and this drives up the prices. Supply and demand, economics 101. If all the middle and lower income people abandon one of these places, the prices will drop like a stone; who wants to live in a city with no police or firefighters or restaurants? Ultra-high prices work OK for small portions of a city, so that service workers can live within commutable distance, but if the ultra-high priced zone grows too large, commuting becomes impractical and something's gotta give. So if you're a line cook at a restaurant, you need to decide whether you want to work for $10/hour in some cheap CoL town, or work for $20/hour in some ultra-expensive place and commute for 3 hours each way. If the wages aren't high enough to entice people to commute, and businesses shut down, the problem will naturally correct itself.