5 ms·
As a paying Spotify member, practices like these only make me want to switch to DRM-free music more. Blackmailing artists with "we won't promote you if you don'
by lucb1e 10y ago
As a paying Spotify member, practices like these only make me want to switch to DRM-free music more. Blackmailing artists with "we won't promote you if you don't lower your prices" and wasting half a million on 2 weeks of exclusivity. That's not what I'm paying them for; I pay them because I want to compensate artists.
- bobsam 10y agoWhat if some artists demand to be compensated more than everyone else? It's a zero sum game after all.
- lucb1e 10y agoI don't understand what you mean by that. I'm talking about promoting artists by pushing their numbers into people's auto-generated playlists (the weekly discovery list and the top charts), not being on Spotify at all.
- thirdsun 10y ago> I pay them because I want to compensate artists. You're paying the wrong people then. If you want to help artists buy their music instead of renting it from streaming services, which may lose access to it at any time.
- tormeh 10y agoLabels take most of that as well. Spotify isn't the problem - the labels are.
- StavrosK 10y agoAren't the labels basically the VCs that enabled the artists to reach you in the first place?
- lucb1e 10y agoIn the old days where you needed to print lots of CDs and distribute them, maybe. These days, I'm not sure they're really necessary. But then I'm not an artist so I can't really say.
- lucb1e 10y agoYeah I've thought about this. Grooveshark tried to cut out that middle-man and they got sued to hell by the labels. If artists keep signing with labels, their problem. You don't need a label to be on Spotify.
- thirdsun 10y ago> Grooveshark tried to cut out that middle-man and they got sued to hell by the labels. Let's call it what it was: Plain piracy. Grooveshark had no rights and licensing in place for the content they streamed.
- lucb1e 10y agoDoes Youtube? Grooveshark complied with DMCA; the only thing they really shouldn't have done is upload music illegally as a policy (by the company itself). But I'm sure there are people who now work at Youtube that also uploaded music there in the past, it's just not official. So yeah it's a bit more piratey than other upload sites, but that could have been solved with a policy change to not upload music illegally from corporate accounts. For artists they were much more accessible than Spotify currently is, but they hated labels for taking a huge cut and didn't make deals up front. I can't say I disagree with them. I still miss Grooveshark.
- thirdsun 10y ago> but they hated labels for taking a huge cut and didn't make deals up front. I can't say I disagree with them. I really think you're misguided here. Sure, evil labels are a welcome narrative for Grooveshark's very illegitimate service. I'm sure you're already familiar with these stories, but to get a taste of how Grooveshark used to deal with artists read this: https://www.theguardian.com/music/musicblog/2011/dec/12/grooveshark-music-site https://www.theguardian.com/music/musicblog/2011/dec/12/groo... Youtube on the other hand is actually used by artists as a promotional tool. And if it isn't their takedown process actually works. Almost too good judging by the stories about false positives in their ContentID system.
- thirdsun 10y agoI'm very tired of this myth. When I see these arguments they usually only cover major labels that operate in big budget, mainstream releases that might indeed be unfavorable to the artist. However the fact that labels come in all forms and colors is often ignored. There are truly caring small, independent and successful labels that serve as curator rather than expensive middleman. Artists can absolutely have fair deals with a label. Furthermore for music enthusiast seeing new releases on a favorite label is a strong indicator for quality. That is a valuable service. Spotify is a problem if it's not sustainable - and it doesn't seem to be for the company and artist alike.
- lucb1e 10y ago> If you want to help artists buy their music instead of renting it from streaming services I'd be paying twice: the artists themselves and the streaming service (which gives part to the artist again). From my all-time favorites I did try buying directly, but they usually don't even have a contact method other than through the label or on a public channel like Twitter. And if I manage to send an email, they don't bother with individuals and just ignore it. Only a few artists have online shops where you can buy directly.
- virgil_disgr4ce 10y agoIf you want to compensate artists, buy their albums on Bandcamp. If they're not on Bandcamp, tell them to get on :)
- lucb1e 10y agoIt doesn't scale to seek them all out individually. I've tried this in the past but it just doesn't work. Usually they don't even have a proper contact method other than through the label or a public channel like Twitter.
- Freak_NL 10y agoIf enough fans ask for it you can be sure that someone in their entourage will pick up the signals (and either act on or ignore them). For smaller acts you can usually find a direct way to contact them somewhere on their website.
- patrickaljord 10y agoPeople don't buy albums anymore, worldwide, they never have (most of it were pirated albums in the rest of the world).