4 ms·
Criteria #2 eliminates Smalltalk. There has been a revival of Smalltalk with Squeak/Gemstone/Seaside. You get very powerful features like continuations that mak
by stcredzero 16y ago
Criteria #2 eliminates Smalltalk. There has been a revival of Smalltalk with Squeak/Gemstone/Seaside. You get very powerful features like continuations that make it easy to write web apps. But speed is a major concern and it also consumes humongous amount of memory.
This is a very bad sign right here for this article -- using hearsay and preconceived notions in place of facts. Smalltalk actually has one of the most efficient memory models for a high-level OO language, and beats Python and Ruby by a big margin. Gemstone is still one of the better VMs out there, and can run circles around Python and Ruby.
What Smalltalk doesn't have is mindshare. That's enough to reasonably eliminate it. Mindlessly parroting preconceived notions in contradiction to the facts is a very bad indicator for article quality.
- wazoox 16y agoWhat Smalltalk haven't either is coherence. See Squeak vs Pharo...
- stcredzero 16y agoWhat incompatibilities is Pharo or Squeak introducing? The ANSI Smalltalk standard is pretty weak, but it does enable a workable compatibility/translation scheme. You'll have to be more specific. Explain how this is any more of a problem than base-library extension name-collision incompatibilities between Rails and other libraries.
- wazoox 16y agoSimply that I'm potentially interested in Smalltalk, and don't know where to start.
- frodwith 16y agoHe tosses a few others languages out on very similar grounds. I confess to not finishing the article out of disgust after he did this several times.