14 ms·
In Berlin, a Grass-Roots Fight Against Gentrification as Rents Soar
- jstewartmobile 10y agoHave to wonder how much of this is occupant-driven vs how much is foreign speculation (like Chinese investment in the Canadian property market). That prices are getting so out-of-whack relative to local incomes in so many places suggests some sort of international aspect...
- phatfish 10y agoOh there absolutely is. In London we welcome anyone with cash to offload, no questions asked. There is plenty of building going on in London, none of which will help anyone on an average wage. It's simply about money. The government loves it because they get a nice payout from stamp duty, estate agents love it because they get to close £1,000,000+ sales, the foreign buyers love it because they can offshore their assets. The only people who don't love it is everyone else.
- sprafa 10y agoI keep wondering whether negative interest rates and QE have made real estate a very attractive purchase for international investors. I'm trying to track down evidence that asset managers have started moving "safe money" investment in that direction to get higher returns than they do from Treasury etc. Which is where that money used to park. It's too widespread of a problem at this point. lisbon, porto, london and Berlin and many other cities like Vancouver are seeing prices explode.
- kjksf 10y agoPresumably those boogeyman foreign investors are rich enough to buy in cash so interest rates have no bearing on their decisions, especially US interest rates. It's not like Chinese peasants get million dollar loans to buy a property in London or that Russian walks into Wells Fargo and gets million dollar loan for a house, even if he's rich in Russia.
- Tiktaalik 10y agoIt's likely investor driven, foreign or otherwise. Toronto for example is in the midst of an incredible real estate bubble, but a professor found that there's more than enough supply being created to keep up with population growth. The problem is extra demand from speculation. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/real-estate/toronto/demand-fuels-toronto-house-prices-not-lack-of-supply-study-finds/article34279980/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/real-estate/toronto/demand-fu...
- timonoko 10y agoLol. When the Green Party gets absolute power, they are very happy to demolish old buildings & environments and replace them with minimum standard housing, and fill them with non-sustainable population, preferably from warmer climates, where such structures are not even needed. "Gentrification" is an american issue. In Europe most governments prevent large-scale private housing projects already, and have to work hard to lure the middle-class into the "multicultural" cities of their own design.
- closeparen 10y ago> fill them with non-sustainable population, preferably from warmer climates, where such structures are not even needed. What does this mean? >most governments prevent large-scale private housing projects already Are you under the impression that large-scale private housing developments are gentrification? In general we should expect that large-scale increases in housing supply would lower rents and prevent gentrification.
- iamdave 10y agoGenuine question: would they prevent gentrification or soften the grueling appearance of it?
- clydethefrog 10y agoWhy would the Green Party go for a no sustainable solution and destroying environments ? Gentrification is an European issue as well. Amsterdam, Barcelona.. you can find many examples of locals getting priced out. Kreuzberg is one of the most "multicultural" parts of Berlin and currently also one of the hippest.
- krautsourced 10y agoAlso one the most expensive places in Berlin to live, btw.
- TillE 10y ago
- blurrywh 10y agoBerlin goes through--I would say--a normal gentrification process. Before 2010 Berlin hadn't have any significant industry and just few jobs. Since then companies, jobs, everything is sky-rocketing and rents get obviously much more expensive. But Berlin is still far below London or Paris. I think we haven't even reached the level of Eastern European capitals price-wise, such as Warsaw. But the actual problem is that the city is super slow in building skyscrapers and rather tries to avoid them 'because they aren't Berlin's DNA'. Skyscrapers offer a much higher density and now is the time to really plan for a couple of them. They are just two new small skyscrapers planned for the next 5-10 years. But it's a very tedious process: everybody is fighting with each other, the city wants guarantees that the real estate funds build and operate schools and other public facilities in those districts, the funds don't want of course. Then there is the subway operator BVG which is kind of blackmailing the funds: They say that the skyscrapers are so heavy and they need money to stabilize the subway tunnels underneath. BTW, they do this with every bigger real estate project (recently with a huge mall). In general, the city's council has a very good feeling about how to plan and build the city, they are really good compared to other cities. Infrastructure is great and you have many small city centers while Berlin-Mitte where the government resides is the busiest and most expensive one (no surprise). They are just lacking one important skill and this is managing large scale projects. Just an example: our new airport which was planned to open 2010 hasn't been opened yet. The new airport seems to be ready but doesn't get the approvals and it seems that it will never get the approvals and has to be shut down again (news from last week). Germany's general overregulation might also play in here. The city currently operates just two small airports. However, they really need to plan proper skyscraper districts which seamlessly integrate with the rest of the city, complement Berlin's DNA and which should have also a good mix of business, leisure and living. So you don't face dead districts at night. The Potsdamer Platz which was created 20 years ago is an ok place which pairs all of those + two tiny skyscrapers.
- smcl 10y agoBTW for anyone curious for more info about the new Berlin airport fiasco Bloomberg did a nice writeup: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2015-07-23/how-berlin-s-futuristic-airport-became-a-6-billion-embarrassment https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2015-07-23/how-berli...
- kalleboo 10y agoFrom the article it sounds like Berlin has tried everything they can think of, aside from actually creating supply to match the demand... In Berlin's case, is it a question of "wanting to keep the cities character", or is it more like the Swedish variant where it's "gotta keep the housing bubble growing"?
- usrusr 10y agoBerlin has supply, the limited resource are vintage buildings (pre-war or rebuilt in the same layout) and no market force can create more of them. The abundant 1970ies style developments will never see gentrification.
- tormeh 10y ago>vintage buildings I don't get the fascination with this. Sure, it's prettier than the Soviet blocks, but that's all they've got going for them. People don't build new buildings that way for a reason. The Soviet blocks are a bad alternative because they were made so cheaply, not because they're newer. I would much rather live in something from this millennium than something "vintage". >The abundant 1970ies style developments will never see gentrification If the city keeps growing and getting wealthier then it will. Ok, maybe they'll have to tear them down and build new or something, but those areas are not "safe".
- pantalaimon 10y ago> Sure, it's prettier than the Soviet blocks, but that's all they've got going for them. That's not true, the big thing they offer is lively streets. First by providing the necessity density (houses in the backyards) and usually come with a commercial space in the ground floor that can be used for a shop, a bar or restaurant. You simply don't find those with new developments, or rather it's the exception then the rule. I guess it's easier to sell a house with a big garage in the ground floor than a bar, but in the end that just leaves the street dead.
- 10y ago
- erikb 10y agoWhen nearly a whole city fights against the investor kind of world view why do people argue that scaring investors away is a bad thing? It's obviously what the people want and DO achieve. You may not be one of them, but they seem to be extremely successful and should be respected for that.
- ptaipale 10y agoThey want to scare the investors away, and instead they want to force others to pay for new housing for them. That doesn't sound entirely reasonable.
- erikb 10y agoThe whole thing is a romantic endeavour more than a logic one. But if you've spent some time in Berlin you can understand the desire to keep things as they are.
- the_mitsuhiko 10y agoBerlin is a great example of what happens if you have bad laws and regulations hit reality. The renter is king in his or her property. Friends wanted to buy a flat but ypu can realistically only rent a flat that comes with an occupant so you need to wait until they leave until you can move into your own property. Then this gets paired with attempts to regulate the increase of the rent and people rent for a bloody long time in a city where there is more demand than housing. The effects this causes in reality then are bizarre. All you have to do is build more stuff and none if this was necessary.
- jonasvp 10y ago> so you need to wait until they leave until you can move into your own property. That's simply false. You can cancel a lease with a renter because of "Eigenbedarf" (personal need) if you want to move into your own property. There's some limitations around it when you buy a property with a renter in it but in general that's how it works. In Germany, the "basic law" (rougly: constitution) says: > (2) Property entails obligations. Its use shall also serve the public good. The state protects your property but this obliges you to also use it for the public good. It's not an absolute right.
- the_mitsuhiko 10y ago> You can cancel a lease with a renter because of "Eigenbedarf" Which has a 10 year "Sperrfrist" (freeze period) and you need to go to court if the renter refuses to honor and make your claim. Even in that case you need to prove your personal need and "living in your own property" does not satisfy that requirement.
- yorwba 10y agoOn the flip side, this means that there is absolutely no need to buy the flat you are living in, because your landlord can't easily throw you out anyway. If you are after the savings in rent, you can still buy a flat and rent it out to pay your own rent.
- allendoerfer 10y ago> After tenant outcry, the city also saved at least two apartment blocks in Friedrichshain-Kreuzberg from being sold, using a legal tool known as the “right of first refusal,” which lets officials intervene if they can find funding for the purchase. In another case, the city recently stepped in and purchased a large disused freight station in the eastern district of Köpenick, which it plans to convert into affordable housing. People like me, living in cities like Munich, Frankfurt or Hamburg, whose rents are much higher than Berlin's and whose taxes fund this, are always happy to help you, Berlin. Just tell us, when your airport is finished, (maybe in 10-20 years?) so we can take a look at what we paid for over there. Berlin is complaining at very high level. If you want to talk about gentrification in Germany, Munich and Frankfurt are the cities to talk about. Berlin has a much easier situation, with much more open space. But when a developer comes along and wants to build skyscrapers on abandoned land, they also complain, because they want to keep their open spaces. The people over there complain about the Swabians, who want to live in these apartments, all that while being financed by the taxes of said people from Southern Germany. I am all for liberal cities and unique culture, but Berlin does not seem to realize, that this is made possible, because Frankfurt, the exact opposite of Berlin, pays for it.
- izacus 10y agoAnd all the money and jobs you have there in Frankfurt and Munch is because rest of us in EU pay for it by buying cars and other crap. This kind of finger pointing is utterly counter-productive. Without Berlin and rest of europe "your" city is a poor dead starving wasteland and we don't go around debating whether Frankfurt can enact a policy because Polish farmers are feeding them are we? What you're doing is essentially trying to move the conversation away from what Berliners think is important - keeping their quality of life.
- allendoerfer 10y ago> And all the money and jobs you have there in Frankfurt and Munch is because rest of us in EU pay for it by buying cars and other crap. Your are welcome to build better cars. Tesla for example is trying to do it, lets see how we respond to that. This is the point of a market-based economy. It is not like we force them to buy stuff. > Without Berlin and rest of europe "your" city is a poor dead starving wasteland. These cities did well, when half of Berlin and most of todays Europe was behind a wall, so I think you are wrong here. > What you're doing is essentially trying to move the conversation away from what Berliners think is important - keeping their quality of life. They can keep there quality of live, I am just asking for a balanced budget. We are happy to pay our share for the additional expenses Berlin has, for being our capital, but other than that, please finance yourself.
- tannhaeuser 10y agoIf there's a housing crisis in Germany, it's entirely the fault of politics. There should be lots of investors in German housing construction projects, given Germany's comparatively low property quote, increasing urban population, and low general interest rates. What turns investors away is the asymetric legal situation unduely favouring the renter's over the owner's interests (I hear in Sweden it's even worse). That, plus excessive laws for energy efficiency that seem to be dictated by the construction industry to drive up initial and ongoing cost. The SPD party's answer is new laws limiting rents (without also attempting to cut down on costs). They shure don't understand how to let the market work for you.
- izacus 10y agoOn the other hand that keeps the quality of life higher for people living in the cities. It's a balancing act between landlord profits and the promise of stability to the citizens. Cities aren't only optimizing for profits of the investors (realtively few people), but also for making life in the city itself happy. And by responses of people moving to Berlin, they're doing something right.
- tannhaeuser 10y agoIt's not about profits for investors so much as it is about a self-sustainable housing economy. Comments like yours, and SPD policies always paint a juvenile "bad investors vs the working class" picture. In reality, investment in housing has always been attractive for smaller investors (eg. Grandma's rent). Especially since the ECB has been keeping interest rates low for the debt-ridden PIGS economies not to collapse. Look at the not-too-distant future, the demographics being what they are. What sustainable investment is there if you have a bit of money to spend for your old days? The problem the SPD is trying to solve with rent-limiting laws will come back massively in ten years time with the then-old generation not having enough to sustain themselves.
- izacus 10y agoNoone is painting investors as bad, but it seems that like a lot of people in this thread you're looking at apartments (living space of citizens of a city) as an investment and not as a basic prerequirement for someone to actually live in a city.
- norswap 10y agoQuestion: does there exist a place today that was like Berlin in the 1990s: civilized but still a bit uncharted, with a lot of opportunities for living thriftily?
- prodmerc 10y agoHonestly, that's like a lot of second/third-major cities in European countries...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pantalaimon 10y agoLeipzig comes to mind
- flohrian 10y agoAlso came to my mind. But Leipzig also attracts many young people because of its affordability. Many things that are true for Berlin now are also true for Leipzig; it is very hip, rents are rising and there's a lack of living space [1][2]. [1]: http://www.taz.de/!5368403/ http://www.taz.de/!5368403/ (german) [2]: https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/535299/umfrage/mietpreise-auf-dem-wohnungsmarkt-in-leipzig/ https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/535299/umfrag...
- pimeys 10y agoDresden too...
- ido 10y agoAll cities (aside from a couple of the capitals) in the formerly-communist EU states.
- et-al 10y agoMany people will say Leipzig, and it's true to a certain extent. Berlin is very unique in its tolerance. As you move eastward in Europe, that may not be the case. Of course if you're white or really attractive, these are non-issues.
- mschuster91 10y agoThe only way left to fight gentrification is, I am afraid to say, something between massive civil disobedience and outright violence. The alternative to fighting - chilling in our sofas and doing nothing - is waking up one day in a city without teachers, cleaning/water/sewer personnel, supermarket staff and, funny enough, police. I just picked these examples as these people are already living near or below poverty line after paying rent and are vital to a healthy city. And: it's not just Berlin that suffers from gentrification, e.g. Hamburg and Munich are falling victim to it. We as people can no longer trust the state (or the police) to serve our interest - both serve the interests of the ultra-rich investors only. Just look at London what awaits societies which do not fight with any means neccessary.
- hungrygs 10y agoFighting gentrification is stupid. Cities with growing populations need new housing supply and the market will put resources (to build) where it meets consumer demand. Unjustifiable barriers to new housing supply will only make prices go up even faster, and for crappier quality housing, too.
- mschuster91 10y agoLOL. The "free market" always goes for building ever more luxury apartments for the rich. Housing is a human right and needs to be regulated as hell, otherwise you end up like London.
- saint_fiasco 10y agoNot saying the market is infallible, but it's often smarter than you and I. When the Invisible Hand builds luxury apartments, it is indeed for the rich, because if the rich don't get the luxury apartments they want, they will settle for middle-class apartments at good locations. Since they are rich, they can outbid all the middle-class people, and only rich people will be able to live at places that used to house middle-class folk. That's what gentrification means.
- Arizhel 10y ago
- aestetix 10y agoBerlin is a very large city. This article covers two districts, Friedrichshain and Kreuzberg, which are experiencing a boom that is starting to raise the rents from insanely dirt-cheap to something people outside Berlin would consider "normal". As it turns out, those two districts also happen to be the most trendy in Berlin. There are many other districts in Berlin that are not affected. For example, I haven't heard much about a rent crisis in Wedding, Alt-Moabit, or any place outside of the Ring-bahn. To put the "crisis" in Bay Area terms, it would be like if it were impossible to find a place to live in the Mission, even though you could still get a place in the Panhandle, and therefore there was an article about a rent crisis in San Francisco, ignoring every other district in the city.
- pantalaimon 10y agoRents are rising across the city and Wedding is gentrifying heavily at the moment, it has seen up to +78% increase in rent since 2009. http://interaktiv.morgenpost.de/berlinmieten/ http://interaktiv.morgenpost.de/berlinmieten/
- aestetix 10y agoA rent increase is not the same as a gentrification crisis. The fact is, this issue is not a product of a supply issue. There is plenty of housing in Berlin, if you're willing to live in a non-trendy area and maybe take an extra stop or two on the train. In places like the Bay Area, there simply is no supply, and therefore there is a crisis.
- hocuspocus 10y agoI assume Wedding gets hit by the price hike pretty badly because it's next to Mitte and the rents were particularly low despite the central location. As long as people don't get displaced, I don't see it as a bad thing, Wedding still looks kinda sketchy and will benefit from more affluent residents in the long run.
- tdj 10y agoNot sure how many do this, but you're basically describing my situation, 8 min commute to Mitte, and relatively cheap. Due to the rent control, rents only jump after tenants change. An identical flat to mine, below me, was just now online available for rent for about 20% more than my rent is - and got rented out within a month, so there's demand. I don't think there's a fear for displacement yet, there's quite a few plots to build up, or abandoned places that are torn down (e.g. Stattbad), and a bunch of new modern apt buildings coming up. But for now, it looks like Neukölln is the more desirable next-hip-thing.
- Overtonwindow 10y agoI am hoping to move to Berlin someday. Hopefully housing will be affordable.
- discardorama 10y agos/Berlin/San Francisco/g Same shit, different place. From a US perspective: The world is changing. The (American) ideal of a McMansion with a 2.5 kids and 3 cars is gone. People want to live in cities; in particular, tolerant, safe, cultured cities. Old timers in San Francisco (where I live) will blame the "tech boom" and "techies" for this phenomenon, but it's not limited to tech, and is not caused by tech. It's just the cycle we are in currently.
- Kequc 10y agoLarge areas of the city did the opposite of gentrify already. So what do you want, of course people in those areas want to move to nicer ones. Stop crapping the whole place up, the few pockets that are still nice are of course going to see higher rent prices. If you don't like gentrification there are plenty of cheap areas in the city for you to live. This article smacks of an agenda. They want the whole city to be bad, it's not enough yet.
- notliketherest 10y agoGentrification aka "supply and demand". Sounds like they haven't even attempted increasing supply in these neighborhoods.
- Pica_soO 10y agoNiemand hat die Absicht einen Flughafen zu bauen.
- kafkaesq 10y agoHousing prices have soared in fashionable Berlin neighborhoods like Friedrichshain-Kreuzberg. Ah, the New York Times. Yes, there is a borough (or district) called Friedrichshain-Kreuzberg, but no one would think of calling it a "neighborhood" (it's split by a river; and not too long ago, the pieces that comprise it were on different sides of The Wall).