3 ms·
I must ask: As a general rule, how many here don't prefer Safari over web-pages-as-apps? A few exceptional cases aside, I'd be willing to bet Safari is a bett
by Groxx 16y ago
I must ask:
As a general rule, how many here don't prefer Safari over web-pages-as-apps? A few exceptional cases aside, I'd be willing to bet Safari is a better browser than whatever "they" can cook up.
- mechanical_fish 16y agoThe flaw in your question is the word "here", as in "people here on HN". Dangrover made an important point in his currently-on-the-HN-front-page blog post: I made this crazy argument to a friend of mine over beer and he countered "but don't people know what websites are?" It made me think. Well, no, as a matter of fact, not really. The web is messy. Webpages link around to each other and, if you're not tech savvy, you can't really keep track of which one you're on or if it's safe to put your bank password into it. Most people don't know if they should search for them or type them into the URL bar. There is one vital feature of the web-page-as-app: navigation. The "Frypaper" app that I downloaded yesterday is guarsnteed to lead me to Stephen Fry's blog, and not to a phishing site. It will do so in one click. It is helpfully labeled with a big picture of Fry with a silly-looking but eye-catching luminous green glow surrounding him, so that I can't help but find the app when I am looking for it. And once I'm inside the Frypaper app I will see the Fry-endorsed experience. I will not have to wonder whether my oddball browser is rendering his stuff right. I will not have to inform Google of anything I do. The cruel fact is that the first step in web navigation - finding somewhere to start clicking - has terrible usability for non-hackers. People don't understand what URLs are. Even those who understand them can barely read them. Google has made billions of dollars exploiting this fact; even I find things on Wikipedia by tabbing to the search bar, typing a word, then clicking the Wikipedia link on the ensuing Google page. (It is, famously, always there.) The amazing thing is that Apple has made the app install process so seamless that apps have better usability than browser bookmarks. And that's why they are better than plain browsers... At least for people who don't read HN. Having said that: I agree with the OP that all the CD-rommish nonsense that app designers put us through actually detracts from the experience. And I do wish it was possible to install browser enhancements on the iPad that persisted from app-to-app; e.g. if I open up a web page from my Twitter client I want to be able to use 1password in that web page.
- Groxx 16y agoA blog by a VC linked to on HN. I don't think the target demographic is particularly broad.
- rooshdi 16y ago"The amazing thing is that Apple has made the app install process so seamless that apps have better usability than browser bookmarks." Exactly my sentiments. So much so, I decided to start a better navigational tool for browsers at favetop.com. Right now, browser navigation is really a turn-off for some users and I think offering them an easier and more stream-lined process will help them dramatically. Like you stated, this is one of the major reasons native apps have become so appealing to casual users. The ease of the experience is a powerful thing.
- ThomPete 16y agoI don't I prefer the apps over Safari as I frankly find the browser experience lagging on a number of areas such as iframes and frames in general.
- frossie 16y agoAs a general rule, how many here don't prefer Safari over web-pages-as-apps? Don't forget that the iPad is also positioned as a "family" device. While most people here would chiefly check email/twitter/RSS/recipes/etc, their kids want to play games. The majority of kids' websites are flash-based, and so that renders the iPad Safari useless, the only option being to download apps or get the laptop out. Some really impressive apps that I think are hard-to-impossible to emulate in a browser right now are the Formula One Timing and Positioning app (which is amazing if you follow F1 racing). Another are games like Broken Sword. But yeah. I'd rather read Google Reader in a browser than an app. It's all about the nature of the content.
- Groxx 16y agoTrue, there are the Flash-clones. Hadn't considered those. I know the average just-uses-it user has a use for pages-as-apps, and there's the Flash-clone market, but I'm primarily interested in the geeky crowd here. Personally, I'd probably use the browser 95%+ of the time, largely because I can customize it and it's consistent across sites. I value consistency & integration higher than a click or two, but I know I'm not everyone. Admittedly, I don't have an iPod/Phone/Pad, largely due to being a poor college student. I have plans to nab one and probably make a couple apps, but not quite yet.
- zmmmmm 16y agoHow about preferring neither? I hate the content apps for exactly all the reasons stated in the article. I feel like I've gone back to 1996 and I'm looking at one of those CD-ROM encyclopedias. But I hate mobile Safari for most of the same reasons as well! Opening new pages is tedious - it takes seconds for a new window to show while it does a pathetic animation dance that uses 2 seconds of my time and achieves nothing (as far as I can tell the new window doesn't even start to load until mobile safari has finished its performance). Flipping back and forward between pages is equally tedious (why oh why didn't Apple use a side swipe gesture, I wonder?). The arbitrary limit of nine of them seems ridiculous. Some of the "cooked" apps with browsers in them are preferable to mobile Safari because at least when they open a new window they do it quickly.
- delackner 16y agoIf you can deal with never using the back button or new-tab button, Safari does provide a wonderful experience compared to the first generation crap dedicated apps. But in a cruel calculated move I'm sure aimed at forcing us all to buy the second iPad, 256mb is just NOT ENOUGH. Nearly every page I open gets reloaded when I switch back to it, or press the back button. Is there a third party browser yet that does sensible caching of rendered content to "disk"?