5 ms·
Curious what you think of relocation financing. One common theme I hear in interviews with rural Americans is that there are no opportunities where they are, b
by nostrademons 10y ago
Curious what you think of relocation financing. One common theme I hear in interviews with rural Americans is that there are no opportunities where they are, but they can't move to the city because the cost of living is such that they could never afford security deposit + 1st month's rent.
OTOH, I know a few founders who have tried to start relocation financing companies, and it just doesn't seem to work. Too much risk on the loans, and not enough demand from the people who would be helped most by them.
- jbhatab 10y agoI think that's interesting. I'd be curious what the economics behind it would be to make it work, but I think that could be a step in the right direction. Realistically, it may come up with the issues you just mentioned of it just not being economical.
- tomrod 10y agoAre people moving to San Francisco or Manhatten only? Is $2k or $3k crazy? Are there groups of people who could room together? Do they have no friends they could temporarily room with while they get on their feet? I came from this life. This is a copout for people afraid to leave their comfort zone. When I moved to Austin, I had plenty of people warn me I would get mugged every time I set foot on the street. Similar outrageous claims have been made regarding every place I've ended up. Nuts to that. We can't let fear rule our lives.
- IslaDeEncanta 10y ago>Is $2k or $3k crazy? For most people here, $500 is crazy. People in rural America tend to be poor.
- tomrod 10y agoI know people in rural America can have limited means. That's my stomping grounds--I lived it. People can stock away $50/month, $30/month, you name it. Low amounts. It adds up quick. And even then, you can get 4 or 5 people in an area who want to move to the city to go, and go. Or a person can join the military to get out, in most cases. Maybe because its late at night, but I feel like I'm coming across unsympathetic. I'm not--I know it's hard to leave. It's not as easy as up and leaving one day. What concerns me is the idea of an apparent lack of desire to put into action the wistfulness of wanting to leave by grandparent comment and other comments in this thread. Rural America is caught in a spiral of increasing costs that it can't dig itself out of. Most everyone knows that. Is it kinder to continue giving sustenance living to people wanting to stay or to open the valve for transferring to cities through housing projects?
- Frondo 10y agoBy your own math, $50 a month adds up to $2,000 in relocation expenses in years. Years where nothing has gone wrong that needs to deplete that relocation fund. It's a nice dream, but it seems like a dream to me. (Also grew up poor, though not as poor as a lot of people.)
- tomrod 10y agoImplicit in what I'm saying is getting together with like-minded local people to pool resources for a move. Once you've found that initial $50, you'll find more margins. Maybe it comes by switching over to lentils, eggs, salt, and multivitamins. Maybe it comes from canceling cable. Maybe it comes by cutting out the internet for awhile while you put the money to better use. Maybe it comes by picking up an early morning newspaper route in the wealthier part of town. Maybe it comes by working at the local Walmart distributor 25 miles away. Maybe it comes by selling the wood on your property, should you have some. The point is that margins for super-saving and liquidation are possible.
- LoonyBalloony 10y ago> People can stock away $50/month, $30/month, you name it. Tell me more about disposable income... whats it like?
- tomrod 10y agoSnark aside, disposable income is possible. Maybe it comes by picking up a side gig, maybe it comes by choosing to avoid drinking/smoking/junk food, maybe it comes by replacing shorter trips (<10 mi) with bike rides. There are dozens to hundreds of margins where individuals can be super-savers. Use a bucket of water and fingers + soap or newspaper instead of toilet paper, use baking soda instead of toothpaste, eat dandelion leaves instead of buying kale, etc. I lived two years among the poorest of the poor in the Philippines, who live on less then $2/day, and I've seen super saving as a necessity for survival. In the US we have wonderful things like food stamps, guaranteed healthcare at ERs, utilities help if you're poor, etc. that take so much of the risk out of life. If you're living on rice + salt + parasite-laden water, cooking your food in a stolen pot by burning coconut shells from your manual labor during the day as a copras harvester (and getting your protein from unripe jackfruit, salted minnows, purloined coconut, and the wild bird that falls into your traps), living in a house that has a thatched roof and split bamboo walls and floors, and you still send your kids to school and pay the $100/year in tuition to get them there, then seeing how to save literally any disposable income makes a whole lot of sense. We're so wealthy in the US that we have little idea what it means to be truly poor.
- user5994461 10y ago> For most people here, $500 is crazy. People in rural America tend to be poor. They had the $500, they just chose to spend it on the latest iPhone.
- tomrod 10y agoMaybe, maybe not. This does happen, of course, but I'm not sure it's generalizable.
- loeg 10y agoGrandparent poster is just making a snarky comment based on recent events. (Republican) congressman Jason Chaffetz recently suggested that poor people should be able to afford healthcare if they skipped buying the latest iphone.
- LoonyBalloony 10y agoMy rent in rural Wisconsin was $200 a month plus utilities. One of my roommates struggled to keep up with even that.
- sndean 10y ago> Is $2k or $3k crazy? Yes. But that's one thing that does keep rural (or even, in my experience, suburban) people from moving to large cities. They really can't imagine paying so much for rent. Some in my family can't even imagine renting an apartment. It's a house or nothing. A cheap-ish house in a rural area seems to win out over a better job in a city, more often than not.
- tomrod 10y agoThis makes a lot of sense to me... This is exactly why I haven't moved to CA!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 10y agoWhen it is 5 or 6 months of your current housing cost, and you're living paycheck to paycheck (if not piling up debt) due to underemployment, yeah, $2k to $3k is crazy.
- russdpale 10y agoYeh 2k or 3k is crazy for most. Most don't have room mates to help pay for that, and that doesn't even help someone with a family.