4 ms·
Talking about "taxpayers" is disingenuous at best - the private loan holders are the ones that made the unwise loans and should be directly losing out. To the e
by mindslight 10y ago
Talking about "taxpayers" is disingenuous at best - the private loan holders are the ones that made the unwise loans and should be directly losing out. To the extent that these private parties have agreements with USG guaranteeing they'll be bailed out, then the proper time to object to that corrupt arrangement was when it was being made!
Debt, in general, must be dischargeable in bankruptcy. Otherwise the practice is equivalent to the gradual reinvention of slavery. Student loans already run afoul of this principle - let's not double down on the corruption merely to delay writing down losses that have already occurred.
- sokoloff 10y agoStudent loans are not dischargable because there is nothing that can be repossessed and you don't want to allow graduates declaring bankruptcy at 21 to wipe out the debt. (Most people with large debt would be better served to immediately declare bankruptcy than to even attempt paying them off.) Under such a system, once lenders stopped lending, college would again become available primarily to the wealthy.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoStudent loans never brought university education to the masses. Cheap-as-free state universities did that.
- mindslight 10y agoYes, that is the justification that the private lenders bought the law with. But it doesn't refute my point. From a policy standpoint, if the realities make it impractical for lenders to lend then papering over those incentives is effectively doubling down on a bad idea. Compromising in order to encourage more of something generally results in system feedback consuming the desired change, with the downsides of the compromise remaining. Fewer college loans would mean that society would have to adapt elsewhere - the K-12 schools couldn't punt any substantive learning until "college", employers couldn't insist on pedigree degrees for every job, the value in funding state universities would be respected, etc. As we're fast finding out, our societal addiction to credit does not help people actually afford things, but creates a de-facto-mandatory system of wealth extraction from the powerless.
- sokoloff 10y agoWhat if the realities make it practical and profitable to lend if that debt is not dischargeable, but make it impractical to lend if that debt is dischargeable? In such a case, it seems worth exploring whether society overall and different segments are better or worse off with each policy. I think that's the case we're in, and even though it would likely help me personally and help my kids, I don't want to return to a world where a pedigree degree is even more restricted to those with, well, pedigrees.
- mindslight 10y agoThe specific realities that I was referring to are that a college education is expensive and expected to be self-funded. While non-discharagability makes it more practical to lend, it does not affect either of those underlying conditions! Instead, it just delays their realization, basically reinventing indentured servitude with college replacing the boat.