4 ms·
> You don't know any developers working on compiled software. I do. I expect your next response will impose qualifiers on "developers" and "compiled software."
by Razengan 10y ago
> You don't know any developers working on compiled software.
I do. I expect your next response will impose qualifiers on "developers" and "compiled software." :)
> my OP - are from people who need a powerful desktop for work.
Your OP said:
> Problem is, Apple doesn't have anything for power users or developers right now.
> I used to say that their laptops are fine
My experience is that their laptops are still more than fine enough for power users and developers.
- nottorp 10y ago> I do. I expect your next response will impose qualifiers on "developers" and "compiled software." > I used to say that their laptops are fine > My experience is that their laptops are still more than fine enough for power users and developers. Well, [part 1] I don't use xcode, i touch type [part 2] and a lot of the stuff i work on involves looong builds and/or going through a few VMs. I also HATE fan noise and I work from home in a quiet room. Part 1 disqualifies the emoji keyboard, part 2 disqualifies anything with laptop-like internals, namely the laptops and the iMacs. I hope that's enough qualifiers :)
- Razengan 10y ago> i touch type ... Part 1 disqualifies the emoji keyboard Why do you keep saying this? The Touch Bar replaces the FN keys, not the keyboard. There are no emojis on the Touch Bar unless you specifically bring them up. You can modify the Touch Bar to only present you with the controls you need. [1] > I also HATE fan noise and I work from home in a quiet room. ... disqualifies anything with laptop-like internals The 2016 MBPs are some of the quietest laptops around [2]. Which computer do you use? Is it a desktop without any fans? [1] https://www.boastr.net/bettertouchtool-touch-bar-customization/ https://www.boastr.net/bettertouchtool-touch-bar-customizati... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/macbookpro/comments/5ffhe4/2016_mbp_owners_how_loud_are_these_things_fans/ https://www.reddit.com/r/macbookpro/comments/5ffhe4/2016_mbp...
- nottorp 10y ago> Why do you keep saying this? The Touch Bar replaces the FN keys, not the keyboard. I use those keys. Without looking down. > Which computer do you use? Is it a desktop without any fans? Let's say I build my systems according to the advice on silentpcreview.com. Apple laptops on full load may be quiet for a laptop, but they have nothing on a custom built desktop.
- Razengan 10y ago> I use those keys. Without looking down. Unless you slide your finger across the keyboard to "count" which FN key is under your finger, you can still use FN keys on the Touch Bar, without looking down; they are in the same positions. The Touch Bar is always within your peripheral vision when you're looking at the screen anyway [1] [2]. > Let's say I build my systems according to the advice on silentpcreview.com. Apple laptops on full load may be quiet for a laptop, but they have nothing on a custom built desktop. Well if you're willing to record/measure the noise of your current machine under your usual workload, I could try running the same tasks on my 15" 2016 MBP to compare. Mind you though, a desktop chassis is usually far away from you, unlike any laptop right under your hands, unless you use it with an external keyboard. So objective noise vs. perceived noise will be different, and have to be compensated for. [1] http://i.imgur.com/En02SKA.jpg http://i.imgur.com/En02SKA.jpg [2] http://i.imgur.com/DIN2fCE.jpg http://i.imgur.com/DIN2fCE.jpg
- unscaled 10y ago> Unless you slide your finger across the keyboard to "count" which FN key is under your finger, you can still use FN keys on the Touch Bar, without looking down; they are in the same positions. If that was true, we could just use an iPad instead of a physical keyboard. But there's a reason people don't like typing on chiclet keyboards or glass, and some developers even go to great lengths of geekery to build custom mechanical keyboards with different types of switches. Typing on glass just doesn't give you the same feedback you get from physical keys. I'm not saying the Touch Bar is not an improvement for many people. Many people (even some developers or professionals) rarely use the F-keys. But there is a certain demographic which deeply cares about the keyboard, and there's no denying parts of this demographic overlapped with that of MBP users.
- oneeyedpigeon 10y agoWhich apps do you use that make such heavy use of the function keys that makes any such difference significant? I'm not sure I'm aware of anything I use on a daily basis that uses the function keys. I use them so rarely, I usually forget that I need to press the fn key first to actually use them, and then I always have to hunt for the fn key; its placement by the home/end keys on my keyboard isn't exactly conducive to frequent use.
- kbutler 10y agoDebugging keyboard shortcuts is the first thing that comes to mind. Esc is also used regularly. I always bind my keyboard to use the fn# keys without pressing "fn", usually in the BIOS, so I only press "fn" for the other special features (brightness, media, etc., that laptop makers map arbitrarily to the fn# keys)
- jasonlotito 10y ago> My experience is that their laptops are still more than fine enough for power users and developers. And My experience is that their laptops are not more than fine enough for power users and developers. Now, why can't we be both right? That your needs are clearly met by the laptop, but others aren't? Are you somehow impacted if people who used to like the products put out are now disappointed by them? That people who were looking to buy new machines spent their money else where and had better results? Do you feel that if these people are right, that somehow this negates your choice and needs? Why are you working so hard to dictate that their needs are unimportant and that your needs are superior?
- Razengan 10y agoBecause it is baffling. None of the complainers seem to be able to say exactly WHY the new MacBooks are bad. • They complain about performance when they're the fastest MacBooks ever, surpassing many competitors and with a very good battery charge-to-perforamce ratio, not to mention the best display ever on a MacBook. • They complain about needing "5 dongles" when you need at most 1 USB/USB-C adapter + sometimes a multiport hub or dock, for almost any use case. • That one guy keeps calling it an emoji keyboard, when there aren't any emoji on the keyboard. • They complain of not being able to touch-type when the physical keyboard is still there. • They complain about noise when these are the quietest MacBook Pros ever, and without willing to show what they're comparing it with. • They say Apple is losing favor with customers when the new MacBooks have outsold everything and Apple has continued to top rankings and stock prices. So yeah. I have the thing in my hands, and I use it daily, and there really hasn't been a better MacBook before. I DO concede that they may be priced a bit too steeply. Meanwhile I only see complaints from people who have clearly never even used the things! It's pretty obvious with their "emoji keyboard" and "dongles everywhere" hyperbole, like going back to the old "Micro$oft" and "Windoze" days. So of course I have to wonder and ask: By WHAT metric are they bad? I can only chalk it down to a concentrated anti-PR effort, or some desperate brand envy (e.g. adamantly putting the blame for LG's monitors — that have now been fixed, by the way — on Apple.)