9 ms·
> Apple doesn't have anything for power users or developers right now. I'm a power user and a developer and I find the 2016 MBPs to be the best laptops around.
by Razengan 10y ago
> Apple doesn't have anything for power users or developers right now.
I'm a power user and a developer and I find the 2016 MBPs to be the best laptops around. My only misgiving was the hefty price. The only "dongle" I needed was a single USB/USB-C adapter but I really don't have to use it most of the time; everything I have — phone, tablet, portable hard disk — works wirelessly.
The battery time (I think you mistyped "life time") estimation was dumb, never accurate or consistent, and people don't mind the lack of it on billions of other mobile devices anyway.
The battery issues with the 2016 MBPs were found to be on the software side and have since then been resolved, and they have been reported to go for 18! hours on a single charge. Certainly lasts me a whole day and then some of non-continuous use.
Re: the LG shielding mishap, you're blaming Apple for a completely different company's product, okay.
> still doesn't serve my demographic
Which demographic and what do you require?
> touch typing hostile emoji keyboard?
What?
- jasonlotito 10y ago> Re: the LG shielding mishap, you're blaming Apple for a completely different company's product, okay. It's a monitor Apple effectively blessed as their monitor replacement. They sold it. So... yeah. Yeah, I do blame them for their lack of due diligence. Why is this their problem? Because, how am I supposed to rely on Apple to meet my needs if they are perfectly happy dropping products a business depends on? > Which demographic and what do you require? Not the OP, but none of the half-dozen developers/tech-oriented people I know who have switched to the latest laptops prefer them over the older ones. I've heard nothing good about them besides being a bit lighter, but that was one person and it was more a "the only thing better is it's a bit lighter" before listing complaints. The complaints range from the touch bar to performance being far worse than older models. Running side by side, it's noticeable just by watching things run. > What? Are you not aware of the touch bar?
- Razengan 10y ago> It's a monitor Apple effectively blessed as their monitor replacement. They sold it. So... yeah. Yeah, I do blame them for their lack of due diligence. Apple don't make the LG Ultrafine Display. Apple offer many other third-party products through their stores, but it's the manufacturer's responsibility to support those. > how am I supposed to rely on Apple to meet my needs if they are perfectly happy dropping products a business depends on? Apple still make amazing 5120×2880, 10-bits-per-channel screens: The Retina iMacs. If your business depends on such screens, you'd get the iMacs, not the MacBooks, or get a MacBook with any of the many third-party 4K displays. > none of the half-dozen developers/tech-oriented people I know who have switched to the latest laptops prefer them over the older ones. Why? > before listing complaints. The complaints range from the touch bar Like? What complaints specifically? > to performance being far worse than older models. They have some of the fastest SSDs on the market [1], their batteries can go up to 18 hours [2], they have the fastest GPUs ever in a MacBook, and how many laptops do you know that have high-DPI Wide Color screens? ---- > Are you not aware of the touch bar? I use it daily, and it's better than the archaic row of limited and cryptic FN keys that it replaces, especially once you've tweaked it a little. [3] FN Keys: • 12 • Have to remember what each number does in each app • Different numbers remain "fixed" for different functions in different operating systems (e.g. F1 for Help, Alt+F4 for Quit.) • Not customizable • Cannot give at-a-glance status without taking up main screen space ---- Touch Bar: • More than 12 • Not limited by physical space • Context-sensitive and adaptive • More types of controls than just buttons (e.g. sliders, color pickers) • Customizable • Can display at-a-glance status such as time, battery etc. ---- As for other companies that offer high-end laptops, take a look at people's experience with Razer for example. [4] All of the over-a-dozen developers/tech-oriented people that -I- know prefer the 2016 MBPs to everything else. They've also outsold all other competitors in just a single month. [5] [1] https://9to5mac.com/2016/11/01/2016-macbook-pro-ssd/ https://9to5mac.com/2016/11/01/2016-macbook-pro-ssd/ [2] https://www.engadget.com/2017/01/13/macbook-pro-battery-issues-will-be-solved-in-a-software-update/ https://www.engadget.com/2017/01/13/macbook-pro-battery-issu... [3] https://alexw.me/2017/01/what-if-you-could-customize-your-new-touch-bar/ https://alexw.me/2017/01/what-if-you-could-customize-your-ne... [4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13785247 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13785247 [5] http://fortune.com/2016/11/09/apple-macbook-pro-sales/ http://fortune.com/2016/11/09/apple-macbook-pro-sales/
- nottorp 10y agoAnother one that defends the laptops when the original article is about a Mac Pro replacement :) > Can display at-a-glance status such as time, battery etc. You look at the keyboard when you type? Not my demographic then, i type too much for that. It's probably fine for you. > All of the over-a-dozen developers/tech-oriented people that -I- know prefer the 2016 MBPs to everything else. They've also outsold all other competitors in just a single month. You don't know any developers working on compiled software. And the mbpros outsell everything not because they don't annoy people, but because there's almost no alternative. Perhaps the Dell Developer Edition laptops, but Apple would have to piss me off more than they have so far for me to try a Dell instead. And again, the article - and my OP - are from people who need a powerful desktop for work.
- Razengan 10y ago> You don't know any developers working on compiled software. I do. I expect your next response will impose qualifiers on "developers" and "compiled software." :) > my OP - are from people who need a powerful desktop for work. Your OP said: > Problem is, Apple doesn't have anything for power users or developers right now. > I used to say that their laptops are fine My experience is that their laptops are still more than fine enough for power users and developers.
- nottorp 10y ago> I do. I expect your next response will impose qualifiers on "developers" and "compiled software." > I used to say that their laptops are fine > My experience is that their laptops are still more than fine enough for power users and developers. Well, [part 1] I don't use xcode, i touch type [part 2] and a lot of the stuff i work on involves looong builds and/or going through a few VMs. I also HATE fan noise and I work from home in a quiet room. Part 1 disqualifies the emoji keyboard, part 2 disqualifies anything with laptop-like internals, namely the laptops and the iMacs. I hope that's enough qualifiers :)
- Razengan 10y ago
- orange_fritter 10y ago> Yeah, I do blame them for their lack of due diligence. While simultaneously absolving yourself of having to do any research. > Because, how am I supposed to rely on Apple to meet my needs I often see people saying Apple owes it to its customers to make x, y, or z product, as if Apple's role in the ecosystem needs to be expanded further. Apple is a company, not a nanny, they don't owe you anything, and I feel we should keep their scope limited rather than expanded.
- nottorp 10y agoFirst, you're defending the laptop, not the desktops. The laptops are still almost okay. Now for some point answers... > The battery time (I think you mistyped "life time") estimation was dumb, never accurate or consistent, and people don't mind the lack of it on billions of other mobile devices anyway. It was accurate as long as you kept doing the same task. For example, I knew how much longer a gaming session or a long build could last on battery. But this is laptop stuff and the original article and my whining is about desktops. > Re: the LG shielding mishap, you're blaming Apple for a completely different company's product, okay. A completely different company's product that is the only solution that makes use of the emoji mbpro's features, is sold and promoted a lot by Apple, and thus endorsed by them on their web site. > Which demographic and what do you require? Independent dev working from home. Running two VMs simultaneously at times, and also using the same computer for entertainment, namely gaming. Working on compiled software, not scp-ing stuff to a server for web development, so I actually need CPU power. I could almost use the trash can, except they want me to pay for two slow video cards that are for some reason labeled "pro". Put in it a nvidia 1050+ and I'll buy it, although I'll be a bit space challenged. Some source trees take a lot of space. I'll even pay extra for the Xeon and ECC ram i don't really need, but give me a video card i can game on. Before you ask, no, the iMac is not a dev's computer. It thermally throttles if you actually use the CPU, and makes laptop-like noise when compiling. No thank you. I've heard even the trash can throttles, and i blame the "pro" video cards. > touch typing hostile emoji keyboard? What you read exactly. Please explain how you touch type on the touch screen that replaced the F keys and how it is useful to me when I, like anyone who works a lot with the keyboard, have memorized every shortcut I use. It's mostly good for emoji in instant messaging, and I don't use that either.
- Razengan 10y ago> First, you're defending the laptop, not the desktops. The laptops are still almost okay. "Problem is, Apple doesn't have anything for power users or developers right now." You complained about everything from Apple across the board, including blaming them for some other company. [1] > Independent dev working from home. Same here. > Running two VMs simultaneously at times, and also using the same computer for entertainment, namely gaming. Ditto, but just one VM; Windows, for some games. Everything I want to play, even very recent games like Paragon [2], runs just fine on the 15" 2016 MBP, in Boot Camp if not inside macOS. > so I actually need CPU power. Haven't experienced any throttling yet, myself. > What you read exactly. Please explain how you touch type on the touch screen that replaced the F keys and how it is useful to me when I, like anyone who works a lot with the keyboard, have memorized every shortcut I use. See [3]. The Touch Bar is always in your vision and I don't have to take my fingers off the keyboard to use it, as opposed to moving my hand to the mouse/trackpad to perform functions that I can now do from the Touch Bar. "Looking" at it is no different than moving your eyeballs a nanometer to look at a menu bar or any other element on the screen. Even if looking at something was such an arduous action, having to continuously refer to a secondary resource (be it your memory, in-app help, keybind settings, or online) to know what each F-number does with each modifier in each context of each app, is considerably more backwards. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13902459 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13902459 [2] https://www.epicgames.com/paragon https://www.epicgames.com/paragon [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13902923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13902923