2 ms·
Psychology is rubbish, that's already established, so there is no need to read this particular study before forming an opinion, or criticizing the study bases o
by nabla9 10y ago
Psychology is rubbish, that's already established, so there is no need to read this particular study before forming an opinion, or criticizing the study bases on it's merits. /s
On the other hand, published psychological studies are probably better than opinion articles, essays etc. So maybe there is some value in it that.
I myself find these four studies in the paper interesting in the context of ambiguity tolerance and critical thinking. Studies in personality and social psychology like these are usually best understood as some sort of cluster analysis.
Most interesting points form the discussion chapter that draws from many other studies:
1. Many of the effect sizes for intellectual humility were relatively small
2. High IH might come together with epistemic curiosity, cognitive ability and ambiguity tolerance.
3. Most personality characteristics display substantial within-person variability across situations. So the studies probably reflected domain specific intellectual humility (IH).
4. Intellectual humility did not correlate with religiosity or political orientation.
5. Indicators for stubbornness, rigidity, narcissism, or defensiveness are not central aspects of low intellectual humility.
- angry-hacker 10y agoMaybe not rubbish, but it sure isn't science. Nice opinion article -- probably.