6 ms·
Long-Term Thinking and Nuclear Waste
- jakub_g 10y agoSemi-related: If you're interested in the topic, I highly recommend "Plutopia" [1] book which describes in great detail the history of plutonium production, and the consequences of it, near Richland, Washington and Ozyorsk (Russia). It significantly changed my view on the nuclear energy. Not necessarily because it's inherently bad, but when big money is at stakes and you have incompetent people managing stuff, things can go pretty wild. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Plutopia-Families-American-Plutonium-Disasters/dp/0190233109 https://www.amazon.com/Plutopia-Families-American-Plutonium-...
- philipkglass 10y agoI will second the Plutopia recommendation, with a caution. The author tries too hard (IMO) sometimes to narratively equate Richland and Ozyorsk in terms of contamination. By the numbers -- and there are numbers in the book -- Ozyorsk suffered far worse contamination. At the Ozyorsk site the ambient environment suffered far worse exposure, plutonium workers suffered far worse exposure, and nearby populations suffered far worse exposure. But that's not to give the Hanford site a free pass. It is creepy and infuriating how the operators undertook casual large scale experiments and covered up accidents. It's doubly infuriating how locals with good plutonium jobs would turn a blind eye to, or turn against, people who were harmed on the job and whose medical/safety complaints threatened the illusion that everything was great.
- ianai 10y agoCan you offer a good link for the Richland site?
- philipkglass 10y agoI read Plutopia about 2 years ago and at certain points I recall searching Google Scholar and HathiTrust for further quantitative information about the Ozyorsk and Richland sites and other topics raised in the book. There is some quantitative information in the book too but I wanted to dive deeper. I don't know if there is any web site that presents the social Faustian bargain of Richland's "atomic city" years as well as the book does.
- bsder 10y agoNUMEC which did plutonium processing was involved in a bunch of this stuff in Western Pennsylvania. http://triblive.com/neighborhoods/yourallekiskivalley/yourallekiskivalleymore/9678472-74/nuclear-corps-materials http://triblive.com/neighborhoods/yourallekiskivalley/youral... http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/03/23/what-lies-beneath-numec-apollo-zalman-shapiro/ http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/03/23/what-lies-beneath-numec-...
- philipkglass 10y agoI consider these passively-stable waste disposal solutions that are supposed to last 10,000-1,000,000 years without maintenance over-engineered and founded on dubious assumptions. I think that something like surface dry cask storage in a dry, geologically stable area is a lot better. The facility should have ongoing monitoring and the capability to re-cask units every few decades or centuries. If there's some weird failure mode that can't be discovered in artificial accelerated aging tests, future caretakers will be much better poised to cope with the problem if they actually have access to the waste. You don't need to try to invent a language that will survive into deep time, you don't have to use gargantuan safety margins to in an attempt to offset the unknowns of deep time, and so on. What if the maintainer-civilization collapses? And what if nobody a thousand years from now knows how to build steel and concrete vessels or detect ionizing radiation? The somewhat cold but IMO correct answer is then those future low-tech humans will not suffer much risk from our spent fuel, relatively speaking. Making steel and concrete, making radiosensitive photographic emulsions -- these are 19th century technologies. If humans of the distant future don't have even 19th-century-equivalent technology, they probably have such high ambient morbidity and mortality from infectious disease that leaking nuclear waste will not much diminish their quality nor quantity of life. Not to mention that the most dangerous components of spent fuel -- short- and medium-lived fission products -- will be diminished a billion-fold or more after 1,000 years pass. Spent light water reactor fuel fresh from the reactor is orders of magnitude more hazardous per unit mass than any stable element. But after 1,000 years or so the hazard is greatly diminished. At that point it's more akin to a mundanely-hazardous waste like cadmium. Nobody plans how to communicate the hazards of cadmium exposure into geological time even though it endures forever.
- cmsmith 10y agoThere is also a lot of more dangerous nuclear material scattered all over the country in bombs and power plants - none of which are designed to last more than a few decades. If society does collapse, and that collapse is not precipitated by total nuclear war, then it seems like the spent fuel won't even be the worst of the nuclear worries out there.
- xvilka 10y ago
- kodfodrasz 10y agoIt amuses me that people so often fall for the "renewables will have their problems solved in 10 years" mantra, while they say that reprocessing nuclear waste won't be solved in 10000 years.
- Animats 10y agoIf it were not for the political problems, it wouldn't be that hard. Pick some hard-rock mountain in an unpopulated geologically stable area that hasn't changed much in the last 20 million years or so. North and South Dakota have mountains like that. Drill tunnels, well above the water table. Encapsulate high level nuclear waste in glass and put that in big stainless steel thimbles. Lower those into holes in the tunnels. France does something like this.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThis was essentially the Yucca mountain initial plan. I found it interesting (having been a Nevada resident at one time) that glass passivation which is both durable and very difficult to reverse, was opposed by interests who want the waste to be stored in such a way that it can be reprocessed into weapons material (or presumably additional fuel). All of the papers on why it glassifying waste was "bad" came from Westinghouse :-)
- justaguyonline 10y agoJust out of curiousity, if that was basically the "initial plan" for Yucca mountain, what did the plan eventually become?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoWell the current current plan is do nothing as far as I can tell. But the original vitrification plan was replaced with a casking plan which allowed the material to be removed (and recovered). The sad thing is that you don't need a lot of 'high security' around a cave filled with vitrified nuclear waste, you can't use the glass for anything useful. But you do if your cave is filled with casks that can be opened and the contents removed and then aggregated into piles, or wrapped around a truck bomb to be distributed by detonating the now 'dirty' bomb.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIt's a damn shame the US won't proceed with the vitrification method; there is ample quantity of glass containing lead from CRTs sitting in warehouses waiting to be recycled (that is not economically feasible to be recycled, so it sits in warehouses) that would be perfect for the vitrification process.
- thangalin 10y agoOur nearest star is a perfectly fine nuclear waste storage facility. Humanity--in much shorter timespans than those proposed for subterranean storage--could perfect a radiation-hardened space elevator, or other mechanism, capable of reliably transporting such waste to low-Earth orbit. Once in space, nudging the dry casks sunward is a solved problem. As of 2004, the estimated cost for a space elevator was $6.2 billion USD.[1] Others have written on this topic[2], but do not account for technological progress. Today it is prohibitively expensive and dangerous to shoot nuclear waste into the sun. In 100 years, the cost per kilogram will have dropped by orders of magnitude and the reliability of orbital delivery will probably exceed five nines. Achieving escape velocity[3] will be a fraction of today's costs. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_elevator_economics#Cost_estimates_for_a_space_elevator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_elevator_economics#Cost_... [2]: http://www.universetoday.com/133317/can-we-launch-nuclear-waste-into-the-sun/ http://www.universetoday.com/133317/can-we-launch-nuclear-wa... [3]: http://www.adastrarocket.com/aarc/VASIMR http://www.adastrarocket.com/aarc/VASIMR
- taktoa 10y agoare you aware of the fact that the Δv to "fall" into the sun is _more_ than the Δv required to get to, for example, Pluto? it would be way cheaper to drop nuclear waste into Jupiter, though limited launch windows could be an issue. dropping nuclear waste into an active volcano would also be more than likely orders of magnitude cheaper.
- sevenfive_ 10y agoShh, he has citations
- jewbacca 10y agoTheir second citation[2] is actually all about this (... I realized as I was 25 minutes into writing my own version). "nudging the dry casks sunward" is still a really bad choice of words, given the massive prevalence of that particular space travel trope. ---- [2] http://www.universetoday.com/133317/can-we-launch-nuclear-waste-into-the-sun/ http://www.universetoday.com/133317/can-we-launch-nuclear-wa...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI get very frustrated when articles like this repeat things like this comment: "“The issue of what to do with nuclear waste is a clear and present danger to every human life within 100 miles of San Onofre,” said Charles Langley of the activist group Public Watchdogs." That is demonstrably untrue, the nuclear waste in dry cask storage is, at most a danger to people within 100 meters of the storage area *should the cask be destroyed." The stuff just sits there. And the casks keep the neutron flux so low that it doesn't even know there is other material nearby. We have examples of this sort of waste that has been 'stored' for thousands of years already, its in the "reactors" in Gabon.
- marze 10y agoDry casks at the reactor site are totally the correct approach. It should be made law, that all high level waste be so stored on site. Also, a investment fund, a modest one, should be created to fund the re packing of the waste 50 to 100 years from now. It is unclear exactly how long these casks will function without leaking. The communities around the reactors benefited economically from the jobs, it is only fair they tend the waste.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dahdum 10y agoAm I correct that you are against nuclear energy? That law sounds like a poison pill with the effect of reducing future plant development. What's wrong with requiring it to be shipped to Yucca Mountain and charging fees into investment funds for long term management? Jobs and benefits for both communities, no?
- marze 10y agoI like nuclear fusion. Fission has the risk of meltdown, and isn't economically competitive without epic subsidies. So yes and no. This current situation is totally ironic and shows just how ignorant people are. The nearby residents didn't object to an operating reactor but do object to casket-encased waste. The risks involved with an operating reactor are enormously larger. Casks are safe.
- colemannugent 10y agoAs one of the comments on the site point out, this is really rooted in radiophobia. By the most conservative estimates we should have fusion that can reliably yield more energy than put in within around 500 years. With fusion (and the energy abundance it will bring) we can transmute that waste into less dangerous elements [1], and perhaps even into useful rare metals. The most interesting thing about this article to me is how they fail to mention the amount of radiation involved. If you are interested in just how big of a scale you need to talk about radiation, I would look at xkcd's brilliant chart [2]. 1: http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/could-fusion-clean-up-nuclear-waste http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/could-fusion-clean-u... 2: https://xkcd.com/radiation/ https://xkcd.com/radiation/
- JohnJamesRambo 10y agoI've always wondered if the fervent pro-nuclear comments that always show up in any thread on the internet, and overwhelm everyone else, are sophisticated astroturfing from the nuclear industry. There can't be that many people ready at any moment to come to nuclear's aid with all the same thoughts pretty much. It's always the same condescending and "oh you are so stupid if you mention any cons about nuclear" tone.
- dang 10y agoPlease don't play the 'astroturfing' card without concrete evidence. An opposing view is not evidence, it just feels like it is: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13902337 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13902337.
- Sami_Lehtinen 10y agoThis is one proposed experimental solution in category "deep geological repository". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onkalo_spent_nuclear_fuel_repository https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onkalo_spent_nuclear_fuel_repo... Related nice documentary where they cover the questions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Into_Eternity_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Into_Eternity_(film)
- kisstheblade 10y agoI never understood what the problem is. This page http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/ http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/ has great information about nuclear energy. The gist is that there are no problems, just "stupid" people ("radiation is scary") and policies. I never really see this referenced anywhere. Is there some problem in this analysis or has this been "debunked" somewhere? It's a very old paper. For example nuclear waste disposal http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter11.html http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter11.html Quote: For nuclear waste, a simple, quick, and easy disposal method would be to convert the waste into a glass — a technology that is well in hand — and simply drop it into the ocean at random locations.5 No one can claim that we don't know how to do that! With this disposal, the waste produced by one power plant in one year would eventually cause an average total of 0.6 fatalities, spread out over many millions of years, by contaminating seafood. Incidentally, this disposal technique would do no harm to ocean ecology. In fact, if all the world's electricity were produced by nuclear power and all the waste generated for the next hundred years were dumped in the ocean, the radiation dose to sea animals would never be increased by as much as 1% above its present level from natural radioactivity.
- philipkglass 10y agoI would say that a significant part of it has been debunked by ongoing events. For example, here the author talks about the then-future AP-600 reactor design that later became the AP1000: http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter10.html http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter10.html "Probabilistic risk analyses yield estimates that a core damage accident can be expected only once in 800,000 years of reactor operation, and that there is less than a 1% chance that this will be followed by failure of the containment. This makes the AP-600 a thousand times safer than the current generation of reactors. It is also much simpler, reducing the number of valves by 60%, large pumps by 50%, piping by 60%, heat exchangers by 50%, ducting by 35%, and control cables by 80%. The volume of buildings required to have a very high degree of earthquake resistance is thereby reduced by 60%. It is estimated that the plant can be constructed in 3 to 4 years. All of these factors contribute to reducing the cost." In actual fact, the AP1000s under construction are more than 3 years behind their original schedules, both in the US and China. Sanmen Unit 1 was originally supposed to take 5 years to become operational and if it starts this year, as currently projected, it will have been 8. Costs have escalated in tandem with schedule slippages. In the 1970s and 1980s EDF in France demonstrated that a steady commitment to reactor builds can produce reactors on a predictable schedule at acceptable cost. The degree of uniformity and long term commitment required seems to be incompatible with market competition. Since EDF ceased to be a state-owned electricity monopoly in France in the late 1990s, it has struggled to build new reactors. Current reactor projects it's involved with are disastrously late and over-budget. Since it no longer has insulation from political oversight and market forces, I will also guess that EDF will not get to just try again until it can complete new-design builds predictably. Per unit of generated energy, measured by human morbidity and mortality, nuclear power has a very good safety record. It has unpredictable schedules and costs that tend to the high side. Some of the proposals for reducing costs are bad (just deregulate nuclear power!); others are worse (make it immune to lawsuits; stop letting the public vote about it; don't let politicians make decisions about it). The elephant in the room is that fossil power doesn't have its externalities priced in while nuclear does (at least to a much greater degree). In theory, a carbon tax could make all kinds of non-fossil energy more competitive against fossil energy without technology-specific incentives from the government. In practice, there are even more members of the public and the donor class who hate internalized emissions costs than who hate nuclear power. Even if you pass a carbon tax now it can be quickly repealed later, as Australia's example shows. Nuclear reactors need to operate for decades to justify their initial construction.