4 ms·
> This is published under our responsible disclosure policy Honest question because I don't know what responsible disclosure protocols are -- is it considered
by dahart 10y ago
> This is published under our responsible disclosure policy
Honest question because I don't know what responsible disclosure protocols are -- is it considered responsible to report large vulnerabilities directly to the public when the company is too slow? Are there no intermediates? No security organizations or advocates, or even businesses in the vulnerability market, who can help to escalate an important issue without potentially making the situation worse temporarily?
I realize this might be a stupid question, and that I need to assume hackers are already ahead of the public, but my armchair security instincts are that real true harm could come from announcing unpatched vulnerabilities to the public, inviting otherwise lazy or opportunist hackers to jump in.
Only based on what I can see here, the timeline in the article is 6 weeks since discovery, and it went from reporting directly to the app maker, who did respond once, then straight to the public. It just seems like there are a metric ton of intermediate steps one could take before announcing publicly.
- anilgulecha 10y agoThis is the standard.. from 30-90 days of initial report to no intent/comment on fixing. If they did show intent of fixing the issue (by responding to his last 2 requests), then most researchers hold off on full-disclosure for some more time (depends usually on if they think the issue is being exploited in the wild or not). In this particular case, given the sequence of events, the disclosure would be considered responsible by the security industry.
- dahart 10y agoThank you. I can accept full public disclosure is currently considered responsible, and is standard practice. My question might be too presumptuous, and I didn't mean to suggest hackernoon did anything wrong here. What I'm really wondering is why there aren't intermediate third party steps between direct contact and public disclosure? Are there no agencies, public or private, that can help escalate the response times? Are there reasons that the security community has come to believe that third parties don't help, or reasons that public disclosure is seen as the safest alternative?
- anilgulecha 10y agoThere were none till recently, but HackerOne seems to the platform that both companies and hackers are using to track security issues, and in a timely manner. So it's not true that 3rd parties are not helping :)
- ethbro 10y agoWhat would a third party do? If the company is made aware of the issue, either they're fixing it or they aren't. If you read up on the history of responsible disclosure, it's the result of a long, hard, and occasionally still fought battle with companies who decide it's cheaper to sue security researchers into silence than patch flaws. Not all companies, but I'd dare say most. Based on that, they're damned lucky they're being given the benefit of 30-90 days.
- dahart 10y ago> What would a third party do? Well, I can certainly imagine a lot of possibilities. This question seems to suggest there are none. If there are none, I'd like to know why, given that it's easy to imagine some. A company can be aware of a security flaw and in a state of fixing it, just not as fast as the reporting party wants, for a variety of both good and bad reasons. A company can be aware of a security flaw and not understand or agree with the reporter's assessment of the seriousness. A company can be aware of the flaw and be planning or fixing it too slowly, and for whatever reason unwilling to communicate intermediate status, nonetheless taking action. A third party's role would be exactly the same that the public has in this situation, namely to scare the company into taking the issue seriously and fixing it quickly. The benefit of going to a third party that could help, instead of the public, would be preventing larger scale damage than is already occurring. A well respected third party could help the company with the security problem understand that the issue is serious and could even offer services to fix the problem, in case the company isn't competent in security matters. Just one imaginary scenario, the third party could be a government organization or enforcement agency that is tasked with internet safety issues, and has the ability to revoke the offending business's right to operate if they fail to comply. I know some companies have been incompetent and malicious, I know that some companies have tried to silence vulnerability reports, but is that reason to assume they all are? Even if we did speculate that it was most companies, is that a good reason to always escalate to the maximum first, before there's evidence of a cover-up attempt? I just don't see how the threat or the act of making the situation even worse is the only possibility, or even the best possibility for the affected users.