3 ms·
> Young people shouldn't feel the need to withdraw and create their own subcultures to gain a sense of belonging or security. We should be incorporating them in
by xg15 10y ago
> Young people shouldn't feel the need to withdraw and create their own subcultures to gain a sense of belonging or security. We should be incorporating them into society, giving them a sense of purpose and belonging, and equipping them to make meaningful contributions.
I'm not sure if this at all possible or even desirable. I'm not a psychologist, but my impression is that a certain degree of exploring identities is an important part of growing up - and that often involves separation from established structures and a change of relationship to family, school, etc, at least for a while. In the past, those spaces were physical, today they are a mix of physical and virtual.
That said, not everyone is rebellious as a teenager and there are many people who easily find their identities as parts if well-established groups. However people are different and I don't think those groups would at any time be desirable for everyone. ( Or if they were, we'd have a scarily homogeneous society)
Of course some subcultures and alternative groups can lead people in bad directions and be in fact harmful to them. But then the task should be to protect against those bad groups - or even better, give people the strength to protect themselves. Even in those cases, it's important to keep in mind why exactly the groups are harmful.
Seeing the existence of sub-cultures per se as the problem seems too simple to me.