4 ms·
> 5. Even in the most developed and ‘democratic’ countries, the System imposes misinformation. Even in the countries that pretend to be the cradle of free speec
by SideburnsOfDoom 10y ago
> 5. Even in the most developed and ‘democratic’ countries, the System imposes misinformation. Even in the countries that pretend to be the cradle of free speech, misinformation is the System’s primary weapon. A weapon they use very well.
I wonder how that would be revisited today. Now misinformation comes from all corners, many factions all vying to misinform their way into being "the system".
The idea that some cyberpunk underground stands in resistance to this "system" is frankly hopeless. Do you want 9-11 truthers and Obama birthers? That's how you get them. Do you want antivaxers and chemtrails believers? Then let them think that they have a secret truth. Do you want the "alt-right" ? This is where it grew.
- throwanem 10y agoIt was ever thus. The rate's increased, for which we have the Internet to thank, but that's the only change, and one not of kind but of degree. Truth and lies compete, and sometimes lies win out. Would you rather there be only pravda?
- SideburnsOfDoom 10y ago> Would you rather there be only pravda? No. You're right. But then I also wouldn't write a manifesto about taking down the Establishment Media. That comes across completely differently now.
- kortex 10y agoI don't think there is a risk of cyberpunks completely censoring the Establishment Media. The point is to level the playing field. Improve the signal-to-noise ratio.
- SideburnsOfDoom 10y agoMy point is that the playing field in the intervening time has indeed become much more level. And the signal-to-noise ratio has certainly not improved: the most noticeable effect is that now the likes of Breitbart and Infowars have seat at the table. Even tables in the White House. I don't want to see a manifesto asking for this outcome that we already have, I want to see a manifesto for how we can mitigate the worst of the resulting damage, while keeping the good parts such as they are.
- kortex 10y agoIndeed. You can't know what's truly true (istina) without some crucible in which free ideas flow, to enable the discourse which moves toward that truth. Free speech is quintessential to escaping the pravda, truthiness-es and alt-facts fed to us. The side effect is that some alt-facts find a safe space to thrive and multiply. I don't think this can be avoided, I think it ultimately is a feature of nature. To use a machine learning analogy, all the pravda out there - everyone's relative truths - is your training set. If you limit your training set, you lose some ability to generalize to the real world.
- 131012 10y agoI love the analogy. I would precise that by doing this kind of ML training, you would learn a lot about those speaking, but not so much about what they talk about.
- 131012 10y agoI love the analogy. I would precise that by doing this kind of ML training, you would learn a lot about those speaking, but not so much about what they talk about.
- SideburnsOfDoom 10y ago> discourse which moves toward that truth Can you demonstrate that the discourse does move towards truth? > all the pravda out there - everyone's relative truths - "relative truth", eh? Is vaccine denial is relative truth? How about "Sandy hook was staged?" how about "Obama is a foreign muslim, and he founded ISIS" ? I know that these beliefs come from a place of ignorance, anger and fear, but weaponising ignorance and fear is not a "discourse which moves toward that truth" and these memes are not a "relative truth", they are a near totality of the opposite. And yet they affect the fate of nations. I certainly don't have answers, but I know that you first have to ask the right questions, and that this manifesto no longer does.
- coldtea 10y ago>I wonder how that would be revisited today. Now misinformation comes from all corners, many factions all vying to misinform their way into being "the system". The System was never a single entity (e.g. just the government) in the first place. As for smaller independent fractions, those are not really relevant, because its a power law that defines what people believe. 20% of the media/outlets/social media accounts/etc set the tone for 80% of reality (and recursively, 20% of those set 80% of the tone).
- narrator 10y agoWhy do you even care about what cyberpunk is if you think resisting "the system" is hopeless? If everything's just fine and any kind of change tp the way things are currently working is futile then it's just a bunch of nerds playing with a grandiose fantasy ultimately leading nowhere. Might as well be Trekkies learning to speak Klingon and arguing about whether Deep Space Nine was better than The Next Generation for all you care.
- SideburnsOfDoom 10y agoEverything is far from fine, I did not indicate otherwise. I did not say that "resisting the system is hopeless", read again. Trying to change things is not futile, but the idea that this cyberpunk media underground will help us has borne toxic fruit, any fix must first grapple with the reality that this strategy was hopeless.