2 ms·
> The cost of the water system ... [is] proportional to the population size... Absolutely not - unless you assume every municipal area has equal population de
by paulmd 10y ago
> The cost of the water system ... [is] proportional to the population size...
Absolutely not - unless you assume every municipal area has equal population density.
You figure water pipe installation costs per mile. There are a lot more miles to get to people's houses in Podunk Nebraska. Overall - trivially disprovable.
> The ... ability to take on debt [is] directly proportional to the population size.
Absolutely not. Trivially disprovable. Compare tax revenue per-capita between Podunk Nebraska and New York City and see what you come up with. And then figure that out over the actual cost to deploy services to that population. Density of tax revenue per square mile is orders of magnitude lower.
Pro tip here: Podunk Nebraska doesn't have water service. They don't have sewer service. They have a well and a septic field, buddy. Because there isn't revenue to provide real services.
I lived in that growing up - and you don't have an accurate picture of what rural life is like at all. We had well water and septic, just like anyone who lived within 5 miles of us.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoPodunk, Nebraska isn't supposed to have city water and sewer. It isn't a city. You only need those things in areas where there is too much population density for wells and septic fields. And then you're just arguing that sustainable cities should pay for unsustainable ones again.