6 ms·
They overstate this stuff, all of the time. My wife was a finance director at a municipal water utility in an old city. Water supply infrastructure wasn't a ti
by Spooky23 10y ago
They overstate this stuff, all of the time.
My wife was a finance director at a municipal water utility in an old city. Water supply infrastructure wasn't a ticking timebomb -- many pipes last literally centuries, and utilities can proactively use sensors and robots to find weak pipes to repair without digging up half the city. They had a capital program that worked, lines were replaced based on risk and there was a reserve for breaks or other failures.
The higher risk area from a cost point of view is sewers. They don't age as well and as we pave move stuff, many older sewers and combined storm/sanitary systems are unsafe and vulnerable.
The Flint issue isn't about old pipes. It's about incompetent engineers who should be criminally charged for incompetence.
- kakarot 10y agoIt's more abouy failed leadership than failed engineering. It has to do with how Flint spread responsibility over their water source so thin that no one was to blame and no one had the full picture. Laziness gave way to corruption. I'm sure there were protests from the engineering team.
- macawfish 10y agoYou do realize that Flint's local government was usurped by an emergency economic manager, right?
- seanp2k2 10y agoDefund or mismanage (due to incompetence, malice, or a mix) government until you cause a disaster, point at the disaster, and blame it on the government...classic Red Team strategy in action.
- macawfish 10y agoRed team is going very hard right now
- kakarot 10y agoI sure do and I realize this was largely the State's fault. I didn't mean to say "Flint spread the responsibility so thin" so much as "The responsibility was spread thin between Flint and the State"
- rmason 10y agoThey already are being charged and sentenced. They will pay for the crime if you count probation for those in charge;<( http://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/michigan/flint-water-crisis/2017/03/13/flint-water-crisis-state-regulators-charged/99132872/ http://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/michigan/flint-water-c...
- paulmd 10y agoThe people in charge will never pay. The investigation says that the crime goes right to the bottom - random people in the MDEQ who did their jobs and didn't rock the boat.
- candiodari 10y agoThe punishment is that if he poisons another set of kids within a year, she gets a higher sentence. Also her job search will be complicated for a year. Yeah. That'll show them. The only solution is to make monitoring the responsibility of people who are impacted. Distribute water quality testing kits that, first, clearly and easily show their results, and can then be mailed to a federal agency. Good luck avoiding those results.
- billions 10y agoOne could argue the Coca Cola company pushed bottled water on US residents in the 1990's. Alternatively, one could argue government standards did not keep up with filtration technology. Unfortunately, US government innovation since the 1960's has failed the test of time. Statistically speaking, the majority of quality of life improvements in the last half century, was seeded by American startups and small business.
- grinich 10y agoDo you have sources/data for any of those claims?
- deelowe 10y agoAgreed. This is some tin foil hat stuff.
- 8note 10y agoThe biggest ones are all from the government: computing and electronics/chip manufacturing GPS/inertial positioning internet new drugs and treatments its government r&d work
- timthelion 10y agoBut that's only a problem with the AMERICAN government. Lots of other governments around the world are doing amazing things, despite corruption being a constant stress on the system.