5 ms·
Controversial opinion: Governments are inherently bad at managing anything that stretches beyond the next election.
by BurningFrog 10y ago
Controversial opinion: Governments are inherently bad at managing anything that stretches beyond the next election.
- electricEmu 10y agoWith that simplistic logic, public corporations are inherently bad at managing anything that stretches beyond the next quarter.
- BuuQu9hu 10y agoWhich is why there are so many large capital private equity groups.
- orangecat 10y agoShort sellers exist. As do elections, but voters have far less incentive to gather and analyze relevant information.
- ubernostrum 10y agoHow do short sellers punish the executives of the company? Even if they lose their jobs, they'll get millions of dollars in "performance" bonuses and millions more in severance in return for running the company into the ground.
- CountSessine 10y agoI wonder how often this really happens though? Often boards will appoint CEOs to dismantle or sell off hopeless companies (disappearing market, obstreperous union, product is turning into a commodity) in a last ditch effort to recover some shareholder value. We can't call those CEOs failures if they manage to get shareholders something as opposed to the nearly nothing they would get if the company went bust. I think a lot of the criticism of Marissa Mayer misses the point that she was appointed CEO of Yahoo, home-page website for people who don't know how to change their home page. The fact that she managed to arrange an exit for Yahoo that wasn't a complete bankruptcy or shutdown is just epsilon-short-of-miraculous.
- rl3 10y agoAnother way to look at it is that she had an entire large tech company at her disposal and managed to do pretty much nothing with it, then pawned it off and jumped out with a golden parachute.
- CountSessine 10y agoNot an equally legitimate way of looking at it in my opinion. This was Yahoo we're talking about. A buyout was the best possible scenario for shareholders. She's been rewarded for rescuing some shareholder value from a burning car wreck. Here's a question you can ask yourself: do you think Verizon got a good deal? I'd be upset if I held Verizon stock because I believe based on everything I know about Yahoo that Verizon shouldn't have purchased them and that it was a bad deal for them.
- LoonyBalloony 10y ago"I wonder how often this really happens though?" Only when it happens to the "right people". ;) ;) wink wink ;) ;)
- funkyy 10y agoThen create an independent organisation handling things with a fixed budget based on % of federal revenue. This should solve this.
- LoonyBalloony 10y agoI think solving the problem would require getting humans out of the process... since we are always our own worst problem. (IMO)
- Spooky23 10y agoSo people say. Yet in my city, for all its warts, clean water has come out of the tap since the mid 19th century, and the poop and rainwater flows away.
- pje 10y agoWhereas startups are inherently good at long-term sustainability.
- badsock 10y ago...in America. There's lots of developed countries where municipal governments are generally well run as a rule, and while there's always grumbling things never get this out of hand. Lead is posion, for pete's sake. Where else in the developed world would poisoned drinking water be allowed for so long? In Canada we had what we consider a big disaster 17 years ago: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/inside-walkerton-canada-s-worst-ever-e-coli-contamination-1.887200 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/inside-walkerton-canada-s-wors... The Premier (equivalent of a governor), was investigated by judicial inquiry, his offices searched, people went to jail, there were payouts for damages - and this is something that only affected a town of 5,000 people. More importantly, it was fixed as fast as possible. My point being: it's not that there aren't screw-ups elsewhere, it's just that they're so rare that they cause a huge scandal and everyone runs around trying to fix things. In America everyone just seems to just get angry at each other and then do nothing. So don't tar governments. They work well elsewhere. America's just doing it wrong.
- Arizhel 10y agoExactly. The question now is: why is American government so broken, and the corollary is: what can we do to fix it? Is American culture simply broken, so that only utterly sociopathic people go into government? Is America just completely filled with people who have been trained from birth to be sociopathic, as evidenced by the way they vote?
- specialist 10y agoEmpowering (electing) people who cannot govern, and are in fact utterly opposed to anyone governing, is having the expected outcome. Because Freedom Markets[tm], booyah!
- Arizhel 10y agoYes, but that doesn't explain why our voters consistently elect such people, while voters in other industrialized nations don't (nearly as much).
- stephen_g 10y agothat's a common idea, but really there's no inherent quality of Governments that make that the case - I think it's more to do with how various Governments are set up. Interestingly enough, I think that regulatory frameworks set up by people who have the idea that Governments are inherently inefficient can actually make it a self-fullfilling prophesy. It's what I've seen, for example, in the Australian telecommunications and electricity markets. The parts that have been privitised are now run 'more efficiently' by underinvesting on maintenance, upgrades etc., all the time with rising cost to the consumer and rising profits, and now when Government intervention is required (you may have heard about the SA blackouts after Elon Musk offered to build them a 100MW grid scale battery within 100 days recently), the Governments can't really do everything they need because they are limited by law of interfering with the 'efficient' markets. Of course, the idea that you could have a competitive power generation market when the cost of entry is so high is ridiculous.
- BurningFrog 10y agoI think the "inherent quality of [democratic] Governments" is this: If a government does something that causes short term pain with much bigger long term gains, it will tend to get voted out of office long before it gets to the "gains" part. The incentives for elected officials is to focus on winning the next election, or perish. Private organizations also have short term pressures, but they're not nearly as short term and drastic. Board members and stock analysts will actually do serious in depth analysis of the long term prospects. The median voter does not.