3 ms·
> What every author Bostrom, Eliezer et al. seem to miss is that there will be a practical mechanism for a digital AGI taking physical control of systems out of
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
> What every author Bostrom, Eliezer et al. seem to miss is that there will be a practical mechanism for a digital AGI taking physical control of systems out of the hands of humans.
No, that's a pretty widely assumed premise, and most authors specifically do anticipate that. (There's actually some dispute about whether any AGI will be capable of growing that capable that fast; the "fast singularity" scenario is not universally accepted. But many authors do recognize and discuss that scenario, and have not "missed" it.)
> So we either incrementally cede power to them, in which case in theory the humans previously controlling the systems are doing so "rationally" and thus see the AGI as better.
Humans are not universally rational, and even if the humans making the decision were rational, they can still make a horrible mistake. As one of many possible failure modes: a group of humans build an AGI and try to hardcode their particular values, utterly fail at extrapolating how the computer will interpret those values, and end up destroyed by it. Or humans build an AGI they think they've programmed appropriately, but fail to implement it correctly.
> Or the system outsmarts the humans controlling the systems in which case it is demonstrating that it is smarter.
A computer can play chess better than any human at this point, which makes it "smarter" in a way, but that doesn't make its values appropriate. If you somehow gave a chess computer enough flexibility in achieving its goal that it consumed the universe to build more computronium so that it can compute better chess solutions, that doesn't make it better than humans, just better at playing chess and building computronium.
In fact, a far more likely scenario than most of the "actively evil AGI" failure modes is the "accidentally broken" AGI: humans aren't its enemy, but we're made of matter that it could put to other purposes.
> There is a tautology here that seems to be ignored: If we create a superhuman-AGI then by default it's goals will be more universally optimal than ours.
"Might makes right" is not a particularly good value system. Supervillains are typically depicted as smarter than the people they defeat. That doesn't make their goals or values better.
And an AGI doesn't even have to be "smart" in the way we normally conceive of intelligence to fail fatally; it doesn't even have to "think" at all to attempt to optimize the wrong value function.
> So if we create one and it decides to maximize paperclips, then that means maximizing paperclips is more optimal goal universally than whatever humans could coordinate as a goal on our own.
I can't even begin to imagine what value system you're using to reach that conclusion. I could imagine someone thinking "if a system were smarter it must necessarily be more morally right", which is blatantly untrue but in an understandable way. But directly describing a system that destroys the universe, including all of humanity, and replaces it with paperclips, as better...
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoWhile the AI FOOM and Hard takeoff options are discussed, I have yet to see a practical breakdown of HOW - like step by step from any of the existential warning people. It's al vagaries. To your other points, you imply too much. The Chess AI that turns into AGI isn't realistic - it's values are "be the best at chess" which it can do with existing computing power. No need to tear the world apart - it would be inefficient. I also never make the might makes right case. All if the examples you give are fantasy and don't reflect what an actual superintelligence might look like. Again, optimization to some narrow goal has too many weak points to take over all of humanity's functions. "if a system were smarter it must necessarily be more morally right", which is blatantly untrue but in an understandable way I'm unconvinced that this is blatantly untrue. "Moral right" is subjective - hence the point. We got to our morals today not through mysticism but empiricism so it's not out of the reach of superintelligence to optimize further.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> Again, optimization to some narrow goal has too many weak points to take over all of humanity's functions. It doesn't have to take over all of humanity's functions to wreak havoc. A hypothetical AI disaster could be one goal-oriented system with a poorly constructed goal and enough initial resources. > I'm unconvinced that this is blatantly untrue. "Moral right" is subjective - hence the point. We got to our morals today not through mysticism but empiricism so it's not out of the reach of superintelligence to optimize further. I think you're making a fundamental and unwarranted assumption here. You're anthropomorphizing "superintelligence" as something vaguely human-like but better. A system doesn't have to be "intelligent" in a sense that relates at all to what humans think of as "intelligent" to be dangerous. It could simply be a "really powerful optimization process". You're romanticizing the notion of a superintelligent being discarding human values and inventing some new moral system that it then follows, and ignoring the possibility of an algorithm no "smarter" than a nanobot instructed to make a copy of itself. That nanobot doesn't have an interesting value system; it doesn't need one to kill everyone and everything, though. And that's not an outcome that, individually or as a species, we should take any pride or "comfort" in. You're also assuming that the ability to destroy the world requires some kind of intelligent process or executive function, and could not possibly be discovered by an optimization process. It wouldn't necessarily come across such a mechanism at random, but may of the approaches we might apply towards the creation of useful AI could provide exceptionally powerful pattern recognition capabilities, and search abilities. As a complete hypothetical off the top of my head, imagine a ridiculously powerful pattern-search program effectively recreating the idea of afl-fuzz ("throw input at a program and find interesting behavior"), and applying it against the mechanisms running it in a sandbox. Improbable, but not wildly impossible, and an agent that succeeded would gain access to additional computation resources that would allow it to do better than the algorithms it competes with. So, now you have a complex pattern-search engine trained to break out of sandboxes...