4 ms·
It's the government's own highway infrastructure that causes the problem. The problem there is that government, vis a vis its role as provider of infrastructure
by philwelch 16y ago
It's the government's own highway infrastructure that causes the problem. The problem there is that government, vis a vis its role as provider of infrastructure, has enabled, incentivized, and encouraged the use of large numbers of automobiles--not that the private automobile industry is at fault.
- ugh 16y agoSo there would be no motorized individual transport if not for streets built by governments? Would we all be taking the train … no, wait, I would guess that train networks are a pretty bad example in this case. So, would we all be flying instead? Riding the bike? Hiking? Despite all it’s shortcomings, motorized individual transport still seems like a pretty sweet deal to me – I can’t really fault the government for forcing everybody and me to pay for the infrastructure, especially if – like you seem to argue – there is no other way to get that kind of infrastructure. Somehow I don’t really think you are making a good case for your argument.
- philwelch 16y agoTrains are a great example, since they're motorized mass transport instead of motorized individual transport, and are more efficient and less ecologically destructive per capita at high densities. In cities that aren't built for cars at the expense of human-scale forms of transportation, cycling and walking are often legitimate options as well. (On cycling, read this about Copenhagen's infrastructure: http://www.sightline.org/research/sprawl/res_pubs/Livable_Copenhagen_reduced.pdf http://www.sightline.org/research/sprawl/res_pubs/Livable_Co...) If the standard is endangering thousands and wreaking ecological destruction at a wide scale, the disastrous choice of designing cities to favor the automobile over other forms of transportation is not only a failure, it's a government failure more so than a market failure.