3 ms·
Yeah, that it was a financial decision is an institutional and regulatory failure. It shouldn't have even been on the table to switch without properly treating
by maxerickson 10y ago
Yeah, that it was a financial decision is an institutional and regulatory failure. It shouldn't have even been on the table to switch without properly treating the different source water.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWell, when your state is broke, you try to cut corners. You cut the wrong corners, people are maimed or are killed. So, I suppose I agree with you that its institutional and regulatory failures in the most general of ways, similar to how Enron would have been considered "a breakdown in internal controls". And those responsible should go to prison and have civil penalties inflicted on them. Has that happened? I don't know.
- malandrew 10y agoEverything is a financial decision at the end of the day. You can't just wish away the laws of economics. Let's say that regulations dictated that they had to spend this money and they didn't have it. Add enough of such regulations and a shrinking tax base and eventually you have an insolvent city. What do you propose we do then? Near as I can tell, it's reasonable to have such regulations so people don't get hurt by people making decisions with consequences they don't understand, but eventually this will lead to insolvency and we need to have a plan to shut down cities that become insolvent and support relocation efforts when that happens.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt would have been better to shut the water off.
- scythe 10y agoSaving $140/day at the risk of $100M damage to infrastructure is not good financial sense. It's the financial sense exercised by the kind of person who expects someone else to pay for the mess, i.e. a government official. A private corporation which was exposed to the liability would have likely chosen to raise the price of water to pay for the corrosion inhibitor, but someone whose job is to manipulate the balance sheet for political gain has a different utility function. We handle this with rules.
- macawfish 10y agoFunny how this discussion is happening just as Trump proposes to cut things like Meals on Wheels and PBS.
- orasis 10y agoIf that private corporation were a mining company in Montana they would choose to take the profits, go bankrupt, and again have the people pay to clean up the mess.
- LoonyBalloony 10y agoAnd thats a wise business decision. But if you want to erase your student loan debt with bankruptcy you're a lazy mooch who should just get a part time job to pay for college like I did back in the '60s. /s
- orasis 10y agoPlease don't disrespect real wisdom by using "wise" in that way. Wisdom is multi-dimensional and holistic. Screwing over people and the environment is a loser move.
- 8note 10y agoa corporation will never have such liability in the US though... they can bribe a politician(s) into putting the risk on the government