4 ms·
What happens when the firm that destroys the coast simply goes out of business afterwards? All the profits they made before the recklessness came to roost has b
by jonknee 16y ago
What happens when the firm that destroys the coast simply goes out of business afterwards? All the profits they made before the recklessness came to roost has been funneled to shareholders around the world.
- riffer 16y agoNot a problem, just require firms that have the potential to inflict substantial costs on the rest of society to carry insurance against such a catastrophe. The pricing mechanism on the insurance will act as an incentive to minimize the real risk to society.
- jonknee 16y agoBut that's regulation... Lots of it actually because the insurance companies need regulated too (lest they default when a huge oil spill occurs).
- anigbrowl 16y agoTwo problems here. 1. they do carry insurance. Their fuel assets are insured by Jupiter Insurance ltd. ( a wholly owned subsidiary of...BP itself. According to their annual report, they consider external insurance a poor economy and carry as little as possible - basically $1 billion per incident, figuring that any overages can be paid for out of revenues. Awesome. http://www.bp.com/liveassets/bp_internet/globalbp/STAGING/global_assets/downloads/I/BP_20-F_2009.pdf http://www.bp.com/liveassets/bp_internet/globalbp/STAGING/gl... 2. OK, so make them carry more insurance...but then you're back to the dead hand of government regulation or whatever you want to call it. And with the best will in the world, sometimes events take place which are beyond our ability to predict. I imagine the government's recent cautious endorsement of more offshore drilling was based on a careful look at the number of rig disasters in recent years, and the assumption that the industry was sufficiently mature to appreciate the importance of risk management. It's kind of ironic that this occurred right after Obama upset the 'ban all drilling' crowd.
- MichaelSalib 16y agoSure! BP could just get an insurance policy from a reputable insurance provider like...AIG. What could possibly go wrong? I mean, a reputable insurance company like AIG would never, ever, ever offer policies for complex products that it did not fully understand for prices so low that it couldn't cover the risks involved. Insurance company officials would never ever ever cut lots of fundamentally unsound deals in exchange for big bonuses. And even if they did, such behavior could never blow up and eliminate a few trillion dollars of value in a massive economic collapse. That's totally absurd. Really now, this "solution" boils down to "assume the existence of insurance companies that act radically differently from any insurance companies we have experience with"...tis much like "now, assume a can opener".
- jdietrich 16y ago"Going out of business" is a product of regulation that artificially separates the assets and liabilities of a corporation from its owners. I expect that the hardcore libertarian argument would be to make bankruptcy conditional on the corporation having insurance sufficient to cover any possible liability - failing that, the shareholders are held fully responsible for their share of the corporation's liability. I'm no Libertarian, but I think it's unfair to characterise their position as being a kind of corporate anarchism.
- cgranade 16y agoActually, I've heard many libertarians argue for precisely a kind of corporate anarchism. That is, at the end of the day, exactly what deregulation really is: removing government from having power over the actions of corporations. Taken to the logical extreme that people such as Rand Paul seem to honestly want, then that implies that a government cannot enforce the conditions of bankruptcy, nor the liability of owners.
- silentOpen 16y agoStraw man, red herring, spotlight... Libertarian != Anarcho-capitalist Stop trolling.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI don't know of a single libertarian that opposes government action to prevent harmful externalities. They may differ on the mechanism (property rights + tort law vs preemptive regulation), but they all believe preventing harmful externalities is a responsibility of the government. You seem to be confusing anarchists with libertarians.
- jbooth 16y agoWe must be operating under different definitions, then, because every libertarian I've ever met expresses their policy goals specifically as being against government action to prevent harmful externalities. "The market will work it out, and it's not government's job to make my decisions for me". From motorcycle helmet laws on upwards (we all pay for head injuries via insurance). It goes on up to a default position of being against regulation on almost everything -- against sarbox on principle, not just the implementation, against regulations regarding offshore drilling most likely until 4 weeks ago and now they're re-evaluating. If your default philosophy is to approach every issue with "less government" as priority #1, you're going to be against government taking action most of the time.