4 ms·
I am crucially aware of all of the "failure" scenarios and I find few of them plausible - even respecting that they are simple thought experiments. What every
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
I am crucially aware of all of the "failure" scenarios and I find few of them plausible - even respecting that they are simple thought experiments.
What every author Bostrom, Eliezer et al. seem to miss is that there will be a practical mechanism for a digital AGI taking physical control of systems out of the hands of humans. Eg. they would need to control the resources around mining or recovering the metal, then building production plants etc... So we either incrementally cede power to them, in which case in theory the humans previously controlling the systems are doing so "rationally" and thus see the AGI as better. Or the system outsmarts the humans controlling the systems in which case it is demonstrating that it is smarter.
There is a tautology here that seems to be ignored: If we create a superhuman-AGI then by default it's goals will be more universally optimal than ours. They may or may not be aligned. However the definition of term is based on the fact that it is "better" in outcome than all manner of humans.
So if we create one and it decides to maximize paperclips, then that means maximizing paperclips is more optimal goal universally than whatever humans could coordinate as a goal on our own.
If we create a subhuman-AGI then we will be able to overcome it's goals by virtue of the fact that we are still superior.
I'll go back to a very old example. An ant can't determine if building the Large-Hadron Collider is an optimal global goal - it's inscrutable to the Ant. All it knows is that it's house and all it's friends were destroyed.
If it is the case that an AGI can in fact take the physical control reigns from humans, then by definition it is smarter and will make a more optimal long term goal than we could - to the point that we probably wouldn't understand what it's doing.
I think the true concern is that we will make something that is superhuman-powerful without being superhuman-intelligent. Like the doomsday machine in Dr. Strangelove, but to me that is an altogether different question.
- dorgo 10y agoI understand what an "optimal solution" might be. But what is an optimal goal?
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoGreat question. More than likely everyone has a different answer, but each person, group, nation etc... has some implicit goals. I would argue the current human goal is "reproduce successfully" as that is what is baked into our genes - I doubt that is actually optimal though. The failed idea of a coherent extrapolated volition (CEV) that came up years ago was (roughly) the idea of using revealed preferences to understand what Humanity's goal is. This would give us a benchmark for what an AGI's goal should be. So if you want to be able to measure the capability of an AGI in comparison to human system, you need to understand the set of goals in humanity and then compare them to the AGI outcomes. The concept of goal direction in AGI is hugely contentious - but make no mistake there needs to be a goal if it is going to actually function at superhuman levels.
- parenthephobia 10y agoHow can a goal be optimal? What does that even mean? Your argument seems to imply that if an AGI tricks us into giving it the ability to destroy us, that's basically okay because its goals are "better" than human goals. Speaking as a human, I don't consider goals that are compatible with the destruction of humanity to be "better" than goals which are aligned with human interests.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoYour argument seems to imply that if an AGI tricks us into giving it the ability to destroy us, that's basically okay because its goals are "better" than human goals. Yea that's about right. I don't consider goals that are compatible with the destruction of humanity to be "better" than goals which are aligned with human interests. Well of course you wouldn't, neither you nor I would possibly understand what a superhuman-AGI does or thinks. I don't think people realize that actually creating a superhuman-AGI is effectively creating a God in all the forms that people interpret it now.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> What every author Bostrom, Eliezer et al. seem to miss is that there will be a practical mechanism for a digital AGI taking physical control of systems out of the hands of humans. No, that's a pretty widely assumed premise, and most authors specifically do anticipate that. (There's actually some dispute about whether any AGI will be capable of growing that capable that fast; the "fast singularity" scenario is not universally accepted. But many authors do recognize and discuss that scenario, and have not "missed" it.) > So we either incrementally cede power to them, in which case in theory the humans previously controlling the systems are doing so "rationally" and thus see the AGI as better. Humans are not universally rational, and even if the humans making the decision were rational, they can still make a horrible mistake. As one of many possible failure modes: a group of humans build an AGI and try to hardcode their particular values, utterly fail at extrapolating how the computer will interpret those values, and end up destroyed by it. Or humans build an AGI they think they've programmed appropriately, but fail to implement it correctly. > Or the system outsmarts the humans controlling the systems in which case it is demonstrating that it is smarter. A computer can play chess better than any human at this point, which makes it "smarter" in a way, but that doesn't make its values appropriate. If you somehow gave a chess computer enough flexibility in achieving its goal that it consumed the universe to build more computronium so that it can compute better chess solutions, that doesn't make it better than humans, just better at playing chess and building computronium. In fact, a far more likely scenario than most of the "actively evil AGI" failure modes is the "accidentally broken" AGI: humans aren't its enemy, but we're made of matter that it could put to other purposes. > There is a tautology here that seems to be ignored: If we create a superhuman-AGI then by default it's goals will be more universally optimal than ours. "Might makes right" is not a particularly good value system. Supervillains are typically depicted as smarter than the people they defeat. That doesn't make their goals or values better. And an AGI doesn't even have to be "smart" in the way we normally conceive of intelligence to fail fatally; it doesn't even have to "think" at all to attempt to optimize the wrong value function. > So if we create one and it decides to maximize paperclips, then that means maximizing paperclips is more optimal goal universally than whatever humans could coordinate as a goal on our own. I can't even begin to imagine what value system you're using to reach that conclusion. I could imagine someone thinking "if a system were smarter it must necessarily be more morally right", which is blatantly untrue but in an understandable way. But directly describing a system that destroys the universe, including all of humanity, and replaces it with paperclips, as better...
- pka 10y agoYou are implicitly talking about being able to objectively measure a goal's "optimality". Unless you believe in absolute morality or the like, there's no such thing as an objective measure. A goal can only be optimal to an agent. In your example, the fact that we pursue science and can destroy ants doesn't mean that their goal is "objectively less optimal". Their goal is absolutely optimal to them, though they can't reach it if it collides with ours. Some goes for a superintelligent AI.