4 ms·
Historically the idea of war having rules has had a very unfortunate past. In WW1, Germany began unrestricted submarine warfare in 1915 and torpedoed the passe
by nostrademons 10y ago
Historically the idea of war having rules has had a very unfortunate past. In WW1, Germany began unrestricted submarine warfare in 1915 and torpedoed the passenger liner Lusitania (filled with neutral civilians). There's a long list [1] of hospital ships deliberately sunk in WW1.
Then in WW2, aside from even more unrestricted submarine warfare and sinkings of hospital ships [2], we also have the firebombings of Dresden, Tokyo, and every other major axis city; machine-gunning of shipwreck survivors in the water; the atom bombs; the impressment of Koreans into service as "comfort women" for Japanese servicemen; forced labor at both axis & allied prisoner camps; the internment of Japanese-Americans in concentration camps; and of course the Holocaust.
Modern-day, there's the My Lai massacre and Obama's attack on a Doctors Without Borders hospital [3]. Probably more too, but you don't hear about them.
The author cites that war has rules because rules are written down, but rules are written down for Wall Street as well. They're just not enforced. And similarly, the laws of war are only enforced on the losing side, or on scapegoats that the actual decision-makers make available as a token sacrifice. When it comes to actually conducting a war, belligerents usually follow just one rule: win.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_hospital_ships_sunk_in_World_War_I https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_hospital_ships_sunk_in...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_hospital_ships_sunk_in_World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_hospital_ships_sunk_in...
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunduz_hospital_airstrike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunduz_hospital_airstrike
- RangerScience 10y agoDoes that then imply there hasn't been a "losing side" to which the Wall Street rules apply?
- nostrademons 10y agoSure there is - it's the ordinary people who make their money through trading their labor and invest it through a retail brokerage. In other words, most likely...you, the reader. Hear that a company is going to beat estimates from your friend the accountant at a party and act on it, and you'll get busted for insider trading. Develop a complex algorithm to identify all the other people who are trading on inside information and do what they do, and chances are nobody will figure out what you're doing. Cheat on your taxes, and you'll get busted for tax fraud. Move earnings through a complex web of offshore subsidiaries in Ireland, Dubai, and the Cayman Islands, and you're technically following the laws of all of those individual countries, but still end up paying less taxes. Start a pyramid scheme through an e-mail chain letter, and you'll get busted. Start a pyramid scheme by creating a ride-hailing app and bringing on progressively wealthier and more powerful investors, and soon you'll own transportation. Borrow lots of money on your credit card, and you'll be dealing with aggressive debt collectors for the rest of your life. Borrow lots of money from banks for a series of increasingly more speculative real estate & casino deals, go bankrupt 4 times, start a reality TV show, run for President, and soon you'll own the world.
- awqrre 10y agoDead neutral citizens can't be forced to go to war, I guess...
- chillacy 10y agoTo be fair the Lusitania was packed with ammunition, so it's a little harder to say it was unjustified, but it definitely was used as allied propaganda to fuel anti-german sentiment. Also as terrible as it is, Japanese internment was ruled constitutional (and is regarded by many as a very terrible ruling). I think your larger point is still true, and rules are for the losers (aka Nuremberg).
- ferentchak 10y agohttp://www.centenarynews.com/article?id=1616 http://www.centenarynews.com/article?id=1616 My understanding is that the Americans were using these ships to carry arms. Is it even in debate anymore that the Lusitania was carrying arms anymore? Hiding bombs under orphans and sick folks is dirty business I recall how much we criticized the Iraqis for doing the same.
- nostrademons 10y agoMy point is that in times of war, belligerents on all sides will resort to dirty business regardless of what the rules of war say. If the Lusitania was carrying arms (which I'd vaguely heard and have no reason to doubt), that'd support my point.
- 24837 10y agoHonestly, I'm not sure if you're trolling. Your first post went on at length (and with sources!) about how rules aren't worth anything because they'd be broken anyway. Example: German submarines attacking a civilian ship in WWI. Unfortunately you missed the most important point in your story - which is that this ship wasn't so innocent and civilian after all. Rather than ignoring the rules, the Germans broke them in retaliation AFTER the Americans had done so first. The message here is not "rules never work", as your first post implies. It's rather "if you (US) brake the rules, expect the others (Germany) to do so as well in retaliation." The fact that Lusitania was carrying arms does not support your initial point but rather changes the story and implications entirely.
- uzoodoo 10y agoOP might not have been aware that Lusitania was filled with ammunition. The point doesn't change. The point is still about how rules aren't worth anything because they'd be broken anyway. Example: Filling a civilian ship with ammunition. It doesn't matter who started it first.
- nostrademons 10y agoI said nothing about whether rules aren't worth anything or not. I said that they will be broken. The former is a normative statement. The latter is a positive one. A lot of my comments here attempt to describe the world as I've observed it, not the world as I'd like it to be. I have plenty of opinions about how I'd like it to be, as well, but I usually don't share them because opinions are like assholes: everybody has one but thinks that others' stinks.
- coolgeek 10y agoUnder what doctrine or reasoning can you compare the DWB hospital strike with My Lai or intentionally striking hospital ships as a matter of policy? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunduz_hospital_airstrike#U.S._investigation.2C_apology.2C_and_reparations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunduz_hospital_airstrike#U.S....