6 ms·
> Munipalities don't do it because they have no money. Why isn't it self-funding? Issue a bond, pay for the network, lease it wholesale to competing ISPs, use
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> Munipalities don't do it because they have no money.
Why isn't it self-funding? Issue a bond, pay for the network, lease it wholesale to competing ISPs, use the lease money to pay back the bond over time. Zero tax dollars.
- rayiner 10y agoThe economics, politics, and logistics are brutal. Say you build out to the whole city of Baltimore, and get 40% to subscribe at a cost of $5,0000 per subscriber.[1] You issue a bond at 4% interest. So you gotta cover $200 in interest per year per subscriber. Say you charge $70 for service, and 60% of your revenue goes out the door in maintenance and customer service.[2] After paying debt service, you have $135 per year to pay down principal. So it takes you 37 years to pay down your principal. 30-year bonds may be practical for a school building, but not so much for a telecom network where you'll need to make ongoing capital expenditures to upgrade the network.[3] Then there is the politics. It's a political non-starter to issue city bonds to build a network you lease out to private ISPs to sell $70/month internet service that poor people and the elderly can't afford. So some sort of cross-subsidy has to be baked into the deal, and that involves charging higher-income customers more than $70/month. But that makes it harder to hit the 40% uptake rate. And if you can't hit that, you're really screwed because the uptake rate drives your per-household cost. And then there is logistics. Who do you pay to maintain said fiber network? Cities have no experience or staff capable of doing it. So you have to create a new department, and staff it (at least in Baltimore) a relatively expensive unionized workforce (which makes it harder to hit your 40% operating margin above). [1], [2] Roughly cribbed from the financials of EBP's network in Chattanooga. [3] The FiOS network is only 10 years old, and Verizon is about to spend a bunch of money to upgrade from GPON to NGPON-2.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoIt seems like the solution there is to buy out the incumbent. Then you get ~100% uptake instead of 40%, which better than doubles your total revenue and lets you start with the existing network rather than from scratch. You could even bring on some of their technical staff.
- amazon_not 10y agoAustralia tried that. Total disaster.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoAustralia was about to try that but then a different government came in that intentionally sabotaged it to prevent their opponents from getting credit for it succeeding.
- mkj 10y agoWell it's still in progress, a bit hard to declare it a disaster yet.
- amazon_not 10y ago> The economics, politics, and logistics are brutal. No on the economics, yes on the politics and again no on the logistics. > Say you build out to the whole city of Baltimore, and get 40% to subscribe at a cost of $5,0000 per subscriber.[1] How did you get that $5,000 number? It's far more than Verizon paid for FiOS and I can't get it to line up with EPB's numbers either. > Say you charge $70 for service, and 60% of your revenue goes out the door in maintenance and customer service. 60% is far in excess of what maintenance and customer service costs. A brand new fiber network does not require significant maintenance and customer service is a small fraction of the monthly cost. > 30-year bonds may be practical for a school building, but not so much for a telecom network where you'll need to make ongoing capital expenditures to upgrade the network. 30 year bonds work just fine for fiber networks. Upgrading active equipment is a minor effort, covered by your operating budget, unlike building the network which is CAPEX heavy. > It's a political non-starter to issue city bonds to build a network you lease out to private ISPs to sell $70/month internet service that poor people and the elderly can't afford. Yes, politics is a problem, but the above isn't what's stopping builds. > And then there is logistics. Who do you pay to maintain said fiber network? You outsource it like everybody else, unless it becomes cheaper to do it in-house. This is a solved problem.
- rayiner 10y ago> How did you get that $5,000 number? It's far more than Verizon paid for FiOS and I can't get it to line up with EPB's numbers either. The network cost $330 million,[1] and has 71,000 subscribers.[2] > 60% is far in excess of what maintenance and customer service costs. http://static.epb.com/annual-reports/2016/media/EPB_2016_Financial_Report.pdf http://static.epb.com/annual-reports/2016/media/EPB_2016_Fin... ($122.6 million in fiber optic revenues, $78.5 million in fiber optic operating expenses). That is 64% of revenues going to operating expenses. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2013/09/17/how-chattanooga-beat-google-fiber-by-half-a-decade/?utm_term=.d84c05ba4ac7 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2013/09/17... [2] http://www.timesfreepress.com/news/business/aroundregion/story/2015/mar/22/high-fiber-choiceepb-attracts-45-percent-home/294234 http://www.timesfreepress.com/news/business/aroundregion/sto...
- 10y ago
- ensignavenger 10y agoDo you have a link for sources 1 and 2, perchance? Also, I don't think you amortized the interest? As you pay down th bond, the interest cost goes down, so you have more to pay towards the principal...
- rayiner 10y agoI cite the sources further down in response to a sibling comment. You're right, I didn't amortize the interest: fixing that brings the pay-off period to a bit under 25 years, not 37.
- amazon_not 10y ago... and less than 10 years once you use the correct numbers. And that's assuming operating costs are 60% before debt service, which is highish.
- amazon_not 10y agoFor those doubting my calculation, here are the correct numbers: https://www.cga.ct.gov/2012/rpt/2012-R-0515.htm https://www.cga.ct.gov/2012/rpt/2012-R-0515.htm At 4% interest, 83 000 subscribers and attributing none of the costs of the fiber network to the smart meter project the payback period is 10 years and 7 months. A far attribution of costs to the smart meter project would bring the payback period to under 10 years.