3 ms·
Well, yes. Not everything the government does is supposed to be about efficiency. The legal system is very deliberately inefficient. We make police and prosecut
by mikeash 10y ago
Well, yes. Not everything the government does is supposed to be about efficiency. The legal system is very deliberately inefficient. We make police and prosecutors jump through all sorts of hoops when investigating and prosecuting crime, because the goal isn't to make their jobs as easy as possible, the goal is to ensure that innocent people don't get convicted.
- danso 10y agoReminds me of when I was robbed in NY and had to go to a police station to talk to a detective. After I described the physical features of the suspect, he had me use an antiquated program that brought up hundreds of suspects' mugshots who were known criminals in the area that matched my description. The computer and software was comically slow, and after paging through about a dozen slowly loading pages of (poorly lighted) mugshots, I gave up. I was initially annoyed at how inefficient that software was, how its slow speed and clunky interface inevitably made it hard to focus on the work of identifying suspects. I could think of a lot of ways to make it easier to filter and interactively rank/pin photos for easier on-the-fly comparison. But then on further reflection, I realized it's probably a good thing that that software is so clunky. Making the software slicker (i.e. as portrayed in CSI shows) could mislead or pressure users (both police and victims) into thinking that their human ability to identify people from mugshots is more accurate than it actually is.
- semione 10y ago>into thinking that their human ability to identify people from mugshots is more accurate than it actually is Identifying in mugshot does nothing, you have to identify suspect in person and detective will interrogate suspect and you both. There are multitude of checks before anything is done. So still failing to understand how good software which could possible show the suspect is the problem? The main reason possibly could be that they(government) cannot hire good programmers who could build useable systems.
- danso 10y agoI know, they ended up catching him and I had to identify him in a lineup. He ended up pleading guilty. Identifying a mugshot isn't "nothing". It can be used as evidence for probable cause in getting a search warrant or at least paying the suspect a visit.