3 ms·
If you believe the job is immoral, yes. IBM supplied computation systems to Nazi Germany, where they were used to carry out the murder of millions of people.
by vkou 10y ago
If you believe the job is immoral, yes.
IBM supplied computation systems to Nazi Germany, where they were used to carry out the murder of millions of people.
Had it done so knowingly, its management should have been taken out back and shot, right alongside the other perpetrators.
- 67726e 10y agoDeporting immigrants who decided to violate the law is in no way comparable to the systematic murder of millions of people. Get a grip.
- jeff_petersen 10y agoAs with every Nazi comparison with the current administration, this is neither helpful nor honest.
- vkou 10y agoI have implied nothing of the sort. I have, however, implied that "Helping the government do its job" has no bearing on the morality of your actions. What the job is does.
- AckSyn 10y agoIt's intellectually dishonest to draw a comparison of IBM helping the Nazi's commit a genocidal action to the US government deporting illegal aliens, and then say "well I didn't _imply_ anything" Either that or you're being deliberately obtuse and are trolling.
- vkou 10y agoIt's intellectually dishonest to dismiss any ethical controversy about your behaviour with "Well, I'm making a lot of money by helping a government do what it wants, so surely I'm in the clear." Palantir assists with quite a number of... Ethically controversial government activities.
- kbenson 10y agoBlanket dismissal of a comparison because it uses include Nazis is not useful. The point of learning from history is to actually be able to compare current events to the past. Putting Nazi Germany on a pedestal as uniquely evil is harmful, in that it prevents us from learning from those mistakes. Using it where unwarranted is also harmful, but we should not got to such lengths to avoid that as to reduce this historical period to uselessness. Comparisons to the current administration are likely overblown, but are not entirely without merit. Comparisons could also be made to past administrations. The important thing is to consider how well the comparison matches, how problematic the features being compared are in each item, and how that works within context. If those that cannot remember the past are doomed to repeat it, so too are those that refuse to consider the past.
- brilliantcode 10y agoFuck IBM too for helping with the holocaust. Palantir and Peter Thiel wouldn't hesitate to do the same. source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust edit: downvote means you deny holocaust and IBM's role in the massacre of Jews
- mikeyouse 10y agoThere's a fair amount of evidence that IBM knew exactly what their customers were doing with their computing systems. There were IBM engineers on site to operate the counters and they had classifications for why they were in the camps (disabled, gay, Jewish) and the methods in which they died - including 'death by gas chamber'. All of that info was being compiled by employees of IBM. http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/1301691 http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/1301691