3 ms·
> It can't be his libertarian philosophy that supports individual self-determination. Why not? Complete self-determination is essentially "Fuck off" to everyb
by bsder 10y ago
> It can't be his libertarian philosophy that supports individual self-determination.
Why not? Complete self-determination is essentially "Fuck off" to everybody else at best and wholesale exploitation at worst.
- muninn_ 10y agoNo it isn't. This is complete hyperbole.
- GauntletWizard 10y agoThis is how modern society works (not that I think it was ever not the case). Many people have 'strong arguments' that 'fair' is defined by things that benefit themselves. Another large portion pays lip service to this by supporting "progressive" causes, while acting in precisely the ways they rail against. Libretarians are as guilty as progressives. While the stereotype of zero regulation is untrue, most would argue only for regulations that benefit them, and believe that regulations that detriment them are the one that are unfair. (As a defense of myself and my position - I do the same, but I also acknowledge that, and consider the fact that most people are arguing in their own self interest an important part of how we achieve 'fair') This is a sardonic and mean-spirited view, but it is a necessary devils advocate - Too much is done with 'hope', not strategy.
- rrggrr 10y agoNot at all true. Self-determination/Libertarianism is not a hermit's existence or a rejection of society as you characterize it. Its society's reliance on individuals to allocate resources as opposed to government. By way of example only... "We" walk by the homeless in DC thinking someone or government should do something about it; but in practice its individuals and groups of individuals having the greatest positive impact in that community. Government provides an excuse for doing nothing.
- arrosenberg 10y agoGovernment that is properly resourced can have an impact at a far superior scale to any individual. Having individuals allocate resources generally winds up with the individual and his friends having most of the resources (Putin, Saddam, the Emirs, the Saudi Royal family, etc.). The government, and only the government, will write a check (or legislate and require others) to build low-cost housing, provide food for poor children, or provide healthcare so that we don't have lepers dying in the streets. That's not a society, and individuals aren't going to do anywhere near enough - they had their opportunity in 1895, and they acted selfishly, which is how we eventually got to 8 hour work days, medicare and social security.