The problem is that everyone has a different idea of what the 1-5 scale means. My girlfriend never gives a 5 except for her favorite movie since nothing can mat

The problem is that everyone has a different idea of what the 1-5 scale means. My girlfriend never gives a 5 except for her favorite movie since nothing can match its greatness. Meanwhile I rate everything 1-star vs 5-star. So I'm not too convinced there's any nuance in star averages, much less a difference between "decent" and "fantastic". It might just be a more divisive movie that averages out to a 3-4.