8 ms·
I'm cynical that this will bring meaningful improvement. Government has given money to telecoms before, and it's only brought us mediocre service, and brought e
by theandrewbailey 10y ago
I'm cynical that this will bring meaningful improvement. Government has given money to telecoms before, and it's only brought us mediocre service, and brought executives huge paydays.
Where's the fiber, Verizon? We (NJ and PA[0]) gave you huge tax cuts 20 years ago for universal fiber service. You and NYC agreed to provide everyone with fiber.[1] Meanwhile, AT&T keeps merging with promises that are meaningless or eventually reneged on.[2]
[0] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bruce-kushnick/verizon-pennsylvanias-com_b_7532008.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bruce-kushnick/verizon-pennsyl...
[1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/03/nyc-sues-verizon-alleges-failure-to-complete-citywide-fiber-rollout/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/03/nyc-sues-verizon...
[2] https://muninetworks.org/content/atts-many-broken-merger-promises https://muninetworks.org/content/atts-many-broken-merger-pro...
- crazyjustin 10y agoI was looking for references like these, thank you. > Pai is proposing an ambitious program whereby the FCC could expand corporate subsidies for building networks while scaling back regulations... Doesn't inspire a lot of confidence.
- jandrese 10y agoWe already tried subsidizing corporations to convince them to build more infrastructure. They pocketed the money and never laid the wires. If you want to do something like this it needs conditions, and the conditions have to have teeth. There needs to be a regulator in charge of making sure the money is actually used to build infrastructure and not to give even larger bonuses to the top management. But that's the antithesis of Pai's agenda, so it is highly unlikely to happen.
- rhino369 10y agoI'm fairly sure that Huffpo piece is misinterpreting the context of universal fiber service. The statutory "minimum for universal broadband availability" was "1.544 megabits per second (Mbps)" in 1996 when Verizon claimed it would increase it to 45Mbps. See 6 Pa. C.S. §3002. 1.544 Mbps is a T1 line. This strongly suggests that universal broadband availability isn't talking about residential mass market, $49.99 dollars a month, but instead, was about about replacing trunk lines. They weren't promising to give every house 45Mbit. They were promising to upgrade T1 lines to T3 lines, which coincidentally operate at 44.736 Mbit/s. This is confirmed by the time frame of these claims. 45Mbit for home house would have been seen as insane for 1996. 56k modems hadn't even been released on the market. AOL had just introduced flat rate pricing. Home networking didn't really even exist. I'm not even sure if FttH was a concept then. Fiber termination was still very expensive (still is really).
- rayiner 10y agoI think offering subsidies to spur private deployment of broadband is a terrible idea. If the market doesn't want to build it, we should think hard about whether we should build it, and if we conclude we should, the government should just build it.[2] That said, the "huge tax cuts" are fictional. Teletruth's idea of a "tax cut" is a company being able to charge any more money than they would have under regulated rates.[1] The "billions" in "tax breaks" are from the companies charging higher rates to their own customers, alleged cross-subsidizing between various services that were previously regulated at different rates, and accelerated depreciation of infrastructure (which came at a time when major parts of the network infrastructure were upgraded to fiber, even if the last mile remained copper). It wasn't the government writing anyone a check, or even giving any company a special tax credit. Also, this bit of conspiracy theorism exactly inspire confidence in the calculation methodology: > Recently, (April 2015) a TV media company decided to not run an investigation we had worked on together about Verizon’s failure to properly upgrade the networks by 2015. After an interview with Verizon by the company, the word ‘liabilities’ entered their vocabulary and they doubted that there was a tax break that came with the Chapter 30 Pennsylvania broadband plan. [1] That is, of course, one of the purposes of deregulation. Governments chronically set regulated rates too low. For example, environmental groups estimate that water/sewer rates nationally are about half of what they should be in order to account for the scarcity of water and the need to maintain and upgrade aging infrastructure. But no elected PUC official wants to raise grandma's water or telephone rates. [2] And if the government does build it, we should ditch the emotional appeals for FTTH and rely heavily on sensible, cost-effect point-to-point wireless.
- baldfat 10y agoThe really maddening part is that if a city or town decides to do their own network because the private companies has left them out they get sued or new laws are passed to kill the project. A) They get money from the government B) They sue local governments that try to do their own networks C) Then FCC gives more money and profits with less competition and less free markets
- rayiner 10y agoI think the lawsuits attempting to shut down those networks are stupid. At the same time, municipalities are the worst possible level at which to build those sorts of networks. Here in D.C., the Metro tracks are in such dire shape that trips scheduled for 25 minutes take 40+ due to train slowdowns. Last summer, tracks were literally catching on fire. In any case, the vast majority of people live in states where municipalities are not banned from building broadband networks. Munipalities don't do it because they have no money. Is Baltimore going to spend a billion dollars building fiber to every household when it's got a billion-dollar pension fund shortfall? Verizon spent over $3 billion to wire up half of NYC. Was New York in a position to do that itself, when it's got a $46 billion pension liability, and a $14 billion liability in the MTA?
- adastra 10y agoThe telcos are running utilities and should be regulated like utilities. And they should especially be regulated this way if they are heavily subsidized build the infrastructure in the first place.