Everything you've said makes sense, but I don't see it being contradictory to what I said. If you decide you want a more nuanced understanding of what a given

Everything you've said makes sense, but I don't see it being contradictory to what I said. If you decide you want a more nuanced understanding of what a given reviewer likes, I think it's better to evaluate different dimensions (Was it funny? Was it violent? etc) than shades of grey* of the same one. * pun not intended :)