3 ms·
> (It would be ironic if you had no idea you were banned and this was how you found out.) It's called shadow banning or stealth banning [1] and it's probably t
by Cthulhu_ 10y ago
> (It would be ironic if you had no idea you were banned and this was how you found out.)
It's called shadow banning or stealth banning [1] and it's probably the most effective way to keep a community clean; explicit bans will anger the user and make them try and circumvent them by using proxies and multiple accounts, often to the point of just posting porn or other offensive stuff. Very hard to get that fixed. Shadow banning on the other hand hides the offensive content from the users, without the user doing it knowing - they can troll all they want, but shadow banning takes away their audience and thus the fun of it.
But yeah, telling people "ur banned" defeats the purpose and I'd really like people to stop doing that. The HN system isn't obvious though. Should have a help link if you can see hidden comments at least.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stealth_banning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stealth_banning
- sillysaurus3 10y agoI asked dang last year whether it was ok to do this, and he said it wasn't a big deal. I was careful to choose someone who knew they were banned -- my entire question revolves around the fact that people who know they're banned still post a lot of HN comments, even for months. They do it in spite of being banned, which is curious enough that I'd like to ask them why.
- arcticfox 10y ago> (It would be ironic if you had no idea you were banned and this was how you found out.) > I was careful to choose someone who knew they were banned These statements seem inconsistent to me
- sillysaurus3 10y agoIt was a joke. Their name is HeavenBanned, so they're obviously fully aware of their situation. This subthread ended up being boring and cluttered up the main topic. If the mods have a problem with what I'm doing, they'll say so. In the meantime, you have both a downvote button and a flag button to employ. I think there was nothing wrong with what I did, right up until it spawned a useless subthread about whether what I did was ok. At this point it's worth detaching, which is frustrating: I really wanted to know the answer to the original mystery! Since I have to vouch a banned user's comment in order to ask them the question, there's no way to ask them without also spawning an offtopic subthread. I was hoping that people would see that it's an interesting subthread and worth giving some leeway to see where it leads. In general, it's ok for subthreads to veer off topic as long as it's intellectually interesting and substantive. Some of the most interesting comments are generated by that kind of process. But it's easy to push it too far, and it doesn't work if people get caught up in metaquestions.
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoThe problem with shadow banning is the lack of notification regarding rule breakage as well as some harmful psychological effects. People who are shadow banned may not realize they did something wrong / against the rules so they may continue saying the same types of things, without getting flagged / downvoted, thinking maybe it's okay. When they find out they were shadow banned it's easy to feel like an idiot especially if the site allows you to review what they posted while shadow banned. I know reddit has taken the stance lately to only use it against spam accounts as it's highly effective against those.