3 ms·
The author of the article published what he claims were emails sent by Bernstein. If the entire story is fabricated, Bernstein's side is "I never sent those ema
by pseudalopex 10y ago
The author of the article published what he claims were emails sent by Bernstein. If the entire story is fabricated, Bernstein's side is "I never sent those emails".
- belovedeagle 10y agoOn the contrary, the emails seem very credible and do not in any way shake my confidence that the entire story is fabricated. The accuser refuses, when asked, to put any accusations into a formal statement, instead relying on making blog posts such as the this. To me that sounds very much like (a) someone deliberately making false accusations and/or (b) someone in need of help for mental illness. I can think of no other reason not to put one's concerns in writing at the first opportunity; can you shed any light on that decision?
- pseudalopex 10y agoBernstein told the author not to mention their prior conversation in his complaint. The author found this suspicious and filed a complaint with the department secretary instead. You know one thing about the author's mental health: he had panic attacks during a very stressful time in his life. Any psychologist can tell you that this has no bearing on someone's truthfulness. Continuing to speculate about his mental health is in very poor taste.
- DashRattlesnake 10y ago> Bernstein told the author not to mention their prior conversation in his complaint. No, he wanted to the author to restate his complete complaint, rather than merely reference previous confidential statements.
- pseudalopex 10y agoThat may well have been all Bernstein wanted, but he told the author to leave out "any reference to the previous conversation".
- thebooktocome 10y agoDid you read the post? The accuser did make several "formal statements", most of which went ignored. > On my return, with an alternate way to stay in the EU secured, I prepared a written complaint and sent it to our department secretary on the 22nd of August... ... > At the beginning of September, I spoke to two people in HR for nearly two hours, answering their follow-up questions about the complaint I had sent them. ... > While in North America, an HR rep contacted me to tell me that I needed to personally meet with yet another person at the university, who is in charge of scientific integrity. I sent this person a copy of the same written complaint I had already sent to HR, and arranged a meeting. So that's four or five people who received a formal, written statement from the accuser, and did nothing in response.