4 ms·
> Legally Google is different... They are required to keep records that brick and mortar businesses do not. > They have a de-facto monopoly as the largest sear
by tomcam 10y ago
> Legally Google is different...
They are required to keep records that brick and mortar businesses do not.
> They have a de-facto monopoly as the largest search provider for the general populace.
> They are a public resource that is a requirement for many of us to use in our day to day lives.
Wait, what? Has the "defacto monopoly" been legally established? They're a "public resource?" Please cite the legal meaning of "public resource" and where it was established through legislation or judicial action that Google is one?
- hadrien01 10y ago> Wait, what? Has the "defacto monopoly" been legally established? I don't know where you live, but on my planet Google has an 80%+ market share.
- amorphid 10y agoPunting on arguing for or against Google being a monopoly or utility, I will say there are a large number of people who trust Google. There are many, many ways that trust can be violated. As my coworker might say, they have a rather large attack surface.
- tomcam 10y agoOnce regulated by the government, there is an even larger attack surface, as we in the USA have learned over the years, most notably with the recent Wikileaks dump.
- Steeeve 10y agohttps://definitions.uslegal.com/d/de-facto-monopoly/ https://definitions.uslegal.com/d/de-facto-monopoly/ Jiminy christmas. I made a comment on hackernews and you're trying to parse it like we're in a court of law. The fact is that Google is different than a mom and pop shop with a video camera. It's ludicrous to suggest otherwise.
- tomcam 10y agoForgive me for quoting you. You started with "Legally Google is different" so I assumed you wanted to talk law or legislation. Also, I don't recall comparing Google to smaller organizations. I may be oversensitive, but when I hear terms like "They are a public resource" I assume you mean that they should therefore be regulated by the government and paid for with tax money.
- Steeeve 10y agoForgive me... I made a flippant comment following this thread of conversation: > Is this really that different from police asking for security camera footage from a convenience store after a robbery? > I think legally, Google is no different than any other business. And when I came back to the thread there was a series of comments parsing my words. I overreacted to the group and you were the target of that over-reaction.
- tomcam 10y agoNo prob! This is important stuff.