3 ms·
> A real historian work. Dan Carlin is great, but you should take his warning that he's not a historian to heart: he enthusiastically speculates and characteri
by fdsfsafasfdas 10y ago
> A real historian work.
Dan Carlin is great, but you should take his warning that he's not a historian to heart: he enthusiastically speculates and characterizes the people in a way a historian would not, and can be very guilty of picking and choosing events to support the narrative he paints. You will almost certainly get a better understanding of the topics from looking at the academic materials from which he bases his own podcasts.
That said, enjoy him—he really does make the topics come alive, and I haven't been satisfied with JUST his podcast after he's piqued my interest. That's a great thing.
- soneca 10y agoI do have the impression of being informed when he is painting a non consensuous picture, but I might be extra cautious in the future. Good warning, thanks!
- tlrobinson 10y ago(He actually literally says "I am not a historian" in this podcast)
- michaelcampbell 10y agoHe says this in every podcast.