3 ms·
Would it be more efficient to have a secondary bus in the home that provides lower voltage and current for IoT type devices? Something like the USB ports built
by mulmen 10y ago
Would it be more efficient to have a secondary bus in the home that provides lower voltage and current for IoT type devices? Something like the USB ports built in to the power outlet but that actually has a single converter in the home with more efficiency.
- Arizhel 10y agoShort answer: NO. This question seems to come up every time there's a discussion like this about low-voltage power. The whole reason we use high voltages in the first place is to reduce resistive losses. Ohm's Law (V=IR) plus the formula for power(P=VI) tell you everything you need to know, which is that power is related to current and resistance by the equation P=R*I^2. So for a given amount of power, if you increase the voltage by a factor of 2, you then decrease the current by a factor of 2, and you reduce the resistance by a factor of 4, so the power lost in transmission is 1/4 as much. If you tried putting 5V USB ports in your house, you wouldn't be able to use wire to connect them to the central power supply; you'd need to use massively-thick copper bus bars. The cost would be astronomical, and you'd need huge channels on the walls to hold them.
- extrapickles 10y agoTo give some context, 5V @ 1Amp takes ~12AWG, which is around the normal size of wiring installed in a typical 120v 20A circuit in the US. Any more current than 1-2A the wiring gets silly. At 5A, which is around the power levels used for LED lighting, you need 6AWG (13 mm^2) wires. These figures were calculated assuming an average of 40' of wire from converter to outlet. A per-room converter would be more reasonable, but you might be better off doing something like using 120vDC so every non-motor device can drop the bridge rectifier.
- fizixer 10y agoYou could do that if you wanted (and it'll be efficient but in a very local sense). But this article is mainly helpful for battery and mobile usage of IoT devices. At home, the biggest energy guzzlers are the components of your HVAC system, heating, air-conditioning, refrigeration, electric stove, etc. Their power consumption scale is roughly a million times that of all the IoT devices combined. You're not saving anything if you're only making IoT power consumption more efficient at home.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y agoGenerally this doesn't work too well because low-voltage distribution is very inefficient. Even at very modest currents, you're going to need huge conductors or else deal with lots of voltage drop. Compare that to a typical switch-mode power supply, which is already very efficient. The quiescent current of a modern, reasonably well designed power supply is basically negligible. The problems of 'vampire draw' have basically been solved for the actual power supply (devices that don't 'sleep' are still an issue, but that's no fault of the supply). Recently I modified some LED fairy lights with a LDR/transistor setup. The quiescent draw during the day is about a tenth of a watt, vs. 6 watts under load. Left plugged in for a year in 'off' mode, that would cost me less than 10 cents. This 'variable clock' switch-mode supply is all about squeezing every bit of battery life you can with a device. It's about making sensors that can be deployed without a power source that last for years instead of months.
- mulmen 10y agoThis is exactly the type of response I was hoping for, thank you. Is this a similar reason to why long distance power lines are of a much higher voltage?
- lutusp 10y ago> Is this a similar reason to why long distance power lines are of a much higher voltage? Long-distance power conductors use the highest practical voltage to avoid what are called "I squared R" losses, so named because the power dissipated in a resistance (like a transmission line) is equal the the square of the current times the resistance. For a given power level, one can obtain that same power with a very high voltage and a proportionally lower current, thus greatly reducing resistive losses in the lines. This is why a million volts is by no means out of the question for long power transmission lines.
- euyyn 10y agoCorrect. And why AC won over DC: It's much easier to step the voltage up for power transmission.
- Ductapemaster 10y agoPoE was created exactly for this purpose! The converters aren't tiny by any means, but they can get pretty darn small if the device doesn't consume much power. Plus, its routable using existing wiring in a house, uses AC to transmit and avoid resistive losses, and is backwards compatible with existing Ethernet tech. Plus if you need internet connectivity, you only need one wire and you can cut your power consumption by ditching WiFi.
- kogepathic 10y ago> [PoE] uses AC to transmit and avoid resistive losses What? PoE (802.3af/at) operates at 48V DC. [0] There is no AC being transmitted in PoE. 48V DC is used to avoid power loss due to small gauge wires in CAT5/6 cables, so they can provide power to devices up 100m as per the Ethernet specification. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_over_Ethernet https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_over_Ethernet