15 ms·
Man, I'm pretty convinced that Vim macros have single-handedly saved me years of my life. They're so incredibly useful that it's made Vim one of the first thin
by tombert 10y ago
Man, I'm pretty convinced that Vim macros have single-handedly saved me years of my life. They're so incredibly useful that it's made Vim one of the first things that I install on any machine.
- cpach 10y agoOut of curiosity, what kind of macros do you run in vim?
- tombert 10y agoA very common thing that happens to me is that I have to take big blocks of JSON, and map all the keys and values into something else, like HTML or CSV. Without macros, this traditionally involves a lot of copy-paste-change-stuff repetition. With a Vim macro, I can happily just do this once, assign it to a register, and repeat as needed, and even store it for later reuse if I want. There are also, littler things, like jumping between HTML tags, or bulk-indents. What makes Vim's macros better (in my opinion) that other editor's macros is that fact that they're simply stored in copy-paste registers, meaning that you can have many of them, store in a different file, copy them off the internet, or compose them together.
- devopsproject 10y agoNot op but here they are really handy for creating and formatting repetitive code blocks. I find it particular useful when making testing\throwaway code. For example, I may be testing a function and wanting to test a few scenarios on many IDs. So I will create a csv list of numbers and then use a macro to format it your csv string will be like this (normally much longer) 134,234,367,4345 Then record the macro: - type "myFunction(" - type ctrl + right arrow (this moves the cursor to after the comma) - type backspace - type ");" - type enter key then run stop recording and run the macro. It will produce: myFunction(134); myFunction(234); myFunction(367); myFunction(4345); Which doesn't seem like a big time saver over regular copy and pasting. And you could have iterated over the csv string with a for loop. This is probably a really contrived and basic example but you find yourself thinking about using a macro anytime you have to do the same keystrokes over and over.
- tspike 10y agoIt's ancient now, but I put together a video 4 years ago demonstrating a simple macro task: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWfBWg8bVTQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWfBWg8bVTQ
- dasil003 10y agoMy favorite use of macros is as a sort of progressive global search and replace on steroids. I have @q bound to Space, so I can record a macro with qq, then hit space to repeat. Since the macro is just a list of commands in a register I can copy it out and edit it to tweak it, once I'm happy with it over a few lines I can make it recursive by adding @q to the end of it. Compared to regex search and replace this is much more malleable, interactive, and ultimately powerful.
- fiddlerwoaroof 10y agoIt's worth remembering that . (i.e. dot) repeats the last edit command. vim-repeat ( https://github.com/tpope/vim-repeat https://github.com/tpope/vim-repeat ) makes this even better. Although, there are still several situations where macros are better, especially things that involve several motions and edits. (I tend to use qw because w is more convenient to hit after @). Also, it's occasionally useful to remember that you can use the double quote character " to paste a macro, edit it and then update it. i.e. ( "ep .... edit ... ^"ed$ )
- fiddlerwoaroof 10y agoAlso, vim-surround is one of those things that, once you've used it for a while, it's impossible to think of editing text without it: https://github.com/tpope/vim-surround https://github.com/tpope/vim-surround
- dasil003 10y agoAny vim user can profit from visiting https://github.com/tpope?q=vim&tab=repositories https://github.com/tpope?q=vim&tab=repositories and trying any one that looks vaguely interesting.
- mkingston 10y agoSomewhere between the default and your binding: @@ repeats the last macro. So you can record your macro, go to your search text, @q, n, then for all subsequent matches @@.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoI had a recent refactor which was basically "take a 5-argument function call split over many lines and replace it with a different 1-argument call". I made a macro that found the code block I wanted, edited it to the desired syntax, saved the file, and opened the next file in the list I had opened. I opened vim for this occasion with `vim $(ag -l STRING_IN_REFACTORED_CODE)`, which used search results as a list of files to open with vim. The most fun vim macro I've made solved a "solve this puzzle before we want to interview you" question. The problem was a URL to request that gave you a response to parse into the next URL, chained about 100 times. The vim macro took the URL in the current line, shelled out to make a network request for the result of `curl` with that line as an argument, and edited the result into the next URL to fetch.
- asymmetric 10y agoWas the puzzle for Rainforest?
- flukus 10y agoA common one is "here's an excel file, can you put these entries in the database". With macros it's easy to do a really complex transform of a line and then repeat it for every line.
- 2muchcoffeeman 10y agoOr the reverse, someone wants a report from some database in some specific format for whatever reason. It's often easier to do a simply query and vim the output rather than use the string functions of the DB.
- mbrock 10y agoSame with Emacs keyboard macros. I use them very often to do similar things to many lines. Usually they involve some combination of search to move the cursor, word-based movement, cut and paste, and insertion. It's such a great feeling to define a one off macro in a few seconds and then rip through a whole file!
- philsnow 10y agoIf you use emacs keyboard macros regularly and find yourself ever re-recording them because you messed them up just a little bit, try out `C-x C-k C-e` (kmacro-edit-macro) sometime. It's life-changing.
- vdnkh 10y agoAm I missing out by not learning Vim? I know enough to get by for git purposes (renaming all picks to s is amazing), but I feel like I'm really productive with Webstorm. There's a ton of great shortcuts and great features (multi-cursoring, intelligent refactoring, customizable search directories, integrated terminal, etc.) that I feel outplay anything I could do with Vim.
- joshlemer 10y agoWebstorm (and all IDEA-family IDEs, as well as most IDEs in general) has a fantastic Vim plugin that allows you to use vim bindings within the text-editor of the IDE. That's what I use and it saves me so much pain. https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/164-ideavim https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/164-ideavim
- mod 10y agoFWIW as a 'real vim' user I typically find these plugins severely lacking. For instance, I've recently tried the ones in Atom and VSCode and they were both incompatible with my normal workflow. In one of them you couldn't save files with :q, for instance. They're works in progress, likely--and I'm still grateful to the teams who work on them. They just weren't enough for me.
- 2muchcoffeeman 10y agoThe Jetbrains plugin is really good. So far I've found that it covers everything I use. Saving is not an issue with Idea since it autosaves and keeps a local history of your changes as you work.
- kilroy123 10y agoMacros can be really powerful. Takes a while to set it up, but well worth.
- tomsthumb 10y agoMy last macro took about 12 seconds. Really complicated ones can take a while if you have very conceptually-heterogenous text structures, but it's literally "start macro + do stuff + finsh macro" -> use macro.
- keithnz 10y agoyes, you are missing out, but not because you HAVE to use Vim, but just because Vims approach is quite different it's worth learning so your mind at leat knows about this whole other approach to editing. I find Vim plugins in most editors are quite good, a true vimer probably doesn't like them as much because they are a blend (but then, they may as well just use Vim itsefl), and for jetbrains stuff, it blends the awesome of vim with the awesome of jetbrains code manipulations.