4 ms·
Well, maybe they don't need to be unifiable - but GR and the standard model are outright contradictory! We live in one universe, so there must be one true story
by whatshisface 10y ago
Well, maybe they don't need to be unifiable - but GR and the standard model are outright contradictory! We live in one universe, so there must be one true story about how it is.
- Koshkin 10y ago> We live in one universe I think this may be an oversimplification.
- beojan 10y agoNevertheless, GR and QFT describe the same universe.
- valarauca1 10y agoWe live in one universe That remains to be proved.
- redial 10y agoWhat needs to be proven is that [if] we live in the only universe. That we live in one universe [where both GR and SM are correct] is not, as far as I know, being debated.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoExcept in Many Worlds. :) Side question - if MW were true, could it lead to universes where either/both of GR and SM were very different? Are there any constraints on theory classes? Is it possible to go past the usual ideas of MW (different physical constants, or maybe some trivial historical differences) to imagine universes with completely different logical/mathematical/causal bases?
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoI always thought it was more that the techniques used to describe interactions in the SM simply don't work when asked to describe gravity. So we have a detailed theory of particle interactions for the three forces, and a very small stub of a dead end which blows up to infinity in a useless way for hypothetical gravitons. From a very native hand-wavey view, I'm not sure this is a surprise. GR describes a rather lovely and smooth view of spacetime, while the SM assumes spacetime just works transparently and effortlessly, and quantum lumpiness somehow happens inside it, with a few relativistic adjustments. It looks possible they're both different ways to think about information, causal relationships, and correlations. There's enough weirdness around quantum ontology to suggest that neither information/state nor causality are so trivially simple they can be taken for granted.