4 ms·
...Interior tried to build its own database to track law-enforcement actions.... The result, the Incident Management Analysis and Reporting System, is a $50
by jessaustin 10y ago
...Interior tried to build its own database to track law-enforcement actions.... The result, the Incident Management Analysis and Reporting System, is a $50 million Database to Nowhere — last year, only 14 percent of the several hundred reportable incidents were entered into it. The system is so flawed that Fish and Wildlife has said no thanks and refuses to use it.
I know, this is normal, and one shouldn't get upset. It just feels like $50M is enough resources to accomplish quite a lot, if it were properly allocated. It feels like people should be in prison for this.
- germinalphrase 10y agoI'm apparently a broken record today - but Jennifer Pahlka (founder of Code for America) recently did a talk at the Long Now Foundation about this topic. Huge numbers are quoted for (relatively) limited government technology initiatives, but a great deal gets wasted - or otherwise inefficiently allocated - due to how procurement rules are written. If this topic interests you, I highly recommend that you listen to her experiences working to fix government technology creation by bringing in modern development practices.
- Retric 10y agoThe technology is only a tiny part of this. The much more expensive part is getting everyone that should be using the system to actually use it.
- jessaustin 10y agoThey're civil servants, not outlaw bikers. If they're told to use a new system, they'll try. If USF&WS says a system is unusable, while BLM NPS and BIA enter only 14% of what should be entered, I'm willing to believe that the system isn't usable by the users who are supposed to use it. Besides we're not talking about that many people. The whole department is only 70k employees, and less than half of those would be in the field. Let's grossly overestimate and say it cost $800 per user to print out some manual binders and tutorial DVDs. That leaves $22M left over for actually building a very-low-volume (TFA says "several hundred reportable incidents" per year) CRUD app and tying it to other relevant systems. Only, after spending that $50M, we got nothing.
- Retric 10y agoSpoken like someone who has never actually done something like this. The general problem is the people building the system don't have authority to force others to use it. Think herding cats at night.
- jessaustin 10y agoSomebody signed off on spending $50M. If they didn't have buy-in from someone who reports to SecInt, that's another monumental screw-up. I have built and deployed systems that lots of users used for their jobs, which were quite a bit more involved than a simple reporting CRUD, and which handled far more than a few hundred transactions a year.
- Retric 10y agoSystem complexity is not what I am talking about. As soon as your talking several agency's it becomes a ridiculous mess. If you get buy in and it's a priory then everything can go really smoothly, but thinking in terms of just technical problems is a tiny park of cross agency systems.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoThat's contrasted with this figure: > The Department of the Interior knows how many wolves and grizzly bears roam its wilds—can’t it keep track of visitors who disappear? The problem is that the grizzly bears are tracked with stoichastic methods. You have 14% reported? Great if you're tracking bear populations - multiply the total tracked by 100/14, and there's your total! But for humans, you need to track 100% of them, which is a much harder problem.