3 ms·
Back in the day browsers competed over user friendly features like popup blockers, even though that technically breaks a web API. Today browsers are so terrifie
by modeless 10y ago
Back in the day browsers competed over user friendly features like popup blockers, even though that technically breaks a web API. Today browsers are so terrified of breaking a web API that they have allowed the mobile web to become a cesspool. Browsing most sites has become intolerable, the more modern the worse. Scrolling freezes for seconds at a time, whole pages jump up and down constantly while you read, scroll-hijacking ads interrupt you, fixed position headers obscure half the page and appear/disappear at random, "mobile-friendly" sites are more often than not worse than desktop sites even on mobile (plus they break deep links), and I can't be the only one who's noticed that even the old popup blockers have stopped working!
- nkkollaw 10y agoI agree with you on performance, but how is the performance related to this: > Today browsers are so terrified of breaking a web API that they have allowed the mobile web to become a cesspool
- modeless 10y agoMost cases of bad scrolling performance could be fixed if browsers would accept some web API breakage and move scrolling to its own thread that JavaScript, layout, and image loading can't ever block.
- chongli 10y agoBrowsers outside the mainstream are still trying. I'm typing this on the Brave browser[0] and it's fantastic at dealing with those obnoxious sites. It has a built in ad blocker and total JavaScript blocking for a site is just 2 taps away. It's amazing how much smoother sites become when you've blocked all their anti-user shenanigans. [0] https://brave.com/ https://brave.com/
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoBecause more and more of them display nothing without js.
- Al-Khwarizmi 10y agoI wonder who tests those mobile websites and what devices they have. The other day, my partner and I tried a popular one in Spain (atrapalo.com) in four different Android devices, including an HTC One M8 phone and a Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 2014 Edition tablet, which were high tier not that long ago. We found it basically unusable in the four devices and ended up going to the PC...
- laurent123456 10y agoI've got four popups/notifications going on this site: a "Show notifications?" from the browser, a JS ad that overlays the whole page, an "Uso de cookie" banner at the bottom, and a "Would you like to translate this page?" from Chrome (ok, this one is not their fault, but still that's a lot of stuff to deal with just for one webpage).
- nolanl 10y ago(Author of the post and Microsoft Edge team member here.) This is actually an active area of discussion for browser vendors, and we're all experimenting with "interventions" that are designed to benefit users at the expense of web developers. Our most recent efforts can be browsed at https://github.com/wicg/interventions https://github.com/wicg/interventions , and you can see things in there like "passive-by-default" event listeners, timer throttling for background tabs and cross-origin iframes, requiring user intent for vibration, etc. Not all of these efforts have been popular with web developers, and some of them may even need to be rolled back. But browser vendors are indeed trying to address this problem! :) You'll note that Chrome, Firefox, Edge, and WebKit representatives are all involved in this effort.