3 ms·

I'm not sure because the above result doesn't say anything about the distribution of such mass, and intuitively since the light cone tips over once you're past

by lloeki 10y ago

I'm not sure because the above result doesn't say anything about the distribution of such mass, and intuitively since the light cone tips over once you're past the event horizon, everything inside is converging towards the singularity following a law that may prevent any black hole inside black hole from existing (but that's way over my head now).

trhway 10y ago
>everything inside is converging towards the singularity singularities are result of the pure abstract model of [mathematically] continuous spacetime. In real live at small scales the continuity gets broken and as one of the results of it we have QM - if you think about a typical large, star sized, black hole than you can see how degenerate matter in the center would provide the opposite pressure against collapse into singularity similarly like it happens in neutron star. The difference here is that in neutron star the limited existing mass of the star limits the resulting neutron degeneracy level achieved. In case of a black hole the process doesn't stop and as more and more mass comes in the degeneracy goes further/higher with the neutrons being pushed into even higher energy levels and starting to be teared apart into separate quarks and gluons, and as even more mass/energy comes in the quarks get teared apart even further one from another with the new pairs of quarks appearing as a result... That would provide the pressure opposing collapse into singularity. The more incoming gravitational mass/energy pressure the stronger the response. Btw, that boiling quark-gluon soup looks suspiciously like something that is hypothesized as what was in the beginning of our Universe ( what could have triggered the Big Bang explosion/expansion? - may be merge with another super-hyper-gigantic black hole).
- pdonis 10y ago
  > In real live at small scales the continuity gets broken This is a common speculation in quantum gravity, but at this point that's all it is: a speculation. We have no evidence that spacetime is not continuous. And given the predicted scale at which continuity would break down if the quantum gravity speculations are correct (about twenty orders of magnitude smaller than the smallest scale we can currently probe), we aren't likely to be able to test those speculations any time soon.
- pdonis 10y ago
  > if you think about a typical large, star sized, black hole than you can see how degenerate matter in the center There is no degenerate matter in the center of a black hole; it's vacuum inside. A black hole is not an ordinary static object with "stuff" inside, that happens to have a radius smaller than the Schwarzschild radius for its mass. It's a fundamentally different kind of thing: it's made of spacetime curvature, and that's all. > In case of a black hole the process doesn't stop and as more and more mass comes in the degeneracy goes further/higher with the neutrons being pushed into even higher energy levels and starting to be teared apart into separate quarks and gluons, and as even more mass/energy comes in the quarks get teared apart even further one from another with the new pairs of quarks appearing as a result... That would provide the pressure opposing collapse into singularity. There have been speculative models along these lines, but none of them have any experimental support. > that boiling quark-gluon soup looks suspiciously like something that is hypothesized as what was in the beginning of our Universe Same comment--there are speculative models along these lines, but none of them have any experimental support. Figuring out a way to test these models, as well as many other different speculative models of the very early universe, is an open area of research in cosmology.

by lloeki 10y ago

trhway 10y ago

>everything inside is converging towards the singularity singularities are result of the pure abstract model of [mathematically] continuous spacetime. In real live at small scales the continuity gets broken and as one of the results of it we have QM - if you think about a typical large, star sized, black hole than you can see how degenerate matter in the center would provide the opposite pressure against collapse into singularity similarly like it happens in neutron star. The difference here is that in neutron star the limited existing mass of the star limits the resulting neutron degeneracy level achieved. In case of a black hole the process doesn't stop and as more and more mass comes in the degeneracy goes further/higher with the neutrons being pushed into even higher energy levels and starting to be teared apart into separate quarks and gluons, and as even more mass/energy comes in the quarks get teared apart even further one from another with the new pairs of quarks appearing as a result... That would provide the pressure opposing collapse into singularity. The more incoming gravitational mass/energy pressure the stronger the response. Btw, that boiling quark-gluon soup looks suspiciously like something that is hypothesized as what was in the beginning of our Universe ( what could have triggered the Big Bang explosion/expansion? - may be merge with another super-hyper-gigantic black hole).

pdonis 10y ago
> In real live at small scales the continuity gets broken This is a common speculation in quantum gravity, but at this point that's all it is: a speculation. We have no evidence that spacetime is not continuous. And given the predicted scale at which continuity would break down if the quantum gravity speculations are correct (about twenty orders of magnitude smaller than the smallest scale we can currently probe), we aren't likely to be able to test those speculations any time soon.
pdonis 10y ago
> if you think about a typical large, star sized, black hole than you can see how degenerate matter in the center There is no degenerate matter in the center of a black hole; it's vacuum inside. A black hole is not an ordinary static object with "stuff" inside, that happens to have a radius smaller than the Schwarzschild radius for its mass. It's a fundamentally different kind of thing: it's made of spacetime curvature, and that's all. > In case of a black hole the process doesn't stop and as more and more mass comes in the degeneracy goes further/higher with the neutrons being pushed into even higher energy levels and starting to be teared apart into separate quarks and gluons, and as even more mass/energy comes in the quarks get teared apart even further one from another with the new pairs of quarks appearing as a result... That would provide the pressure opposing collapse into singularity. There have been speculative models along these lines, but none of them have any experimental support. > that boiling quark-gluon soup looks suspiciously like something that is hypothesized as what was in the beginning of our Universe Same comment--there are speculative models along these lines, but none of them have any experimental support. Figuring out a way to test these models, as well as many other different speculative models of the very early universe, is an open area of research in cosmology.