7 ms·
>Things become black holes by being dense, not by having large mass. not really. The larger the mass the less dense it has to be when it fits into its Schwarzs
by trhway 10y ago
>Things become black holes by being dense, not by having large mass.
not really. The larger the mass the less dense it has to be when it fits into its Schwarzschild radius. For example, our visible Universe - 46B ly radius - has Schwarzschild radius of 13.7B ly (that number sounds strangely familiar, isn't it? and may give rise to various speculations :), ie. it would have to be just 64 times denser that it is now, ie. like 64 atoms/m3 instead of the current 1 atom/m3.
According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarzschild_radius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarzschild_radius :
"The Schwarzschild radius of an object is proportional to the mass. "
Thus we can see that given the same density mass grows as a cube of the radius of containing sphere, and thus Schwarzschild radius of such a mass would grow as a cube of that sphere radius too. So if a mass grows it is possible for it to lose density pretty fast, like the sphere's radius square fast, and still fit into its Schwarzschild radius.
- OscarCunningham 10y agoSo if it turns out that the whole universe is at least 64 times larger than the visible portion then we are in fact already in a black hole!
- mlonkibjuyhv 10y agoIt would give an "intuitive" explanation to why we can only see the inside of the universe.
- kobeya 10y agoNo explanation needed if the age of the universe is finite.
- akvadrako 10y agoThe universe is expanding in volume, but not mass. Thus some years ago the current visible portion did fit inside a 14Bly radius.
- pdonis 10y ago> if it turns out that the whole universe is at least 64 times larger than the visible portion then we are in fact already in a black hole! No. The universe is expanding. If it were a black hole, it would not be expanding.
- OscarCunningham 10y agoActually I think I just gave the Big Crunch hypothesis. The universe can be expanding so long as it eventually collapses. Even in a normal black hole forming out of a star, some particles will happen to be heading out as the star collapses and then be dragged back in after the black hole forms.
- pdonis 10y ago> Actually I think I just gave the Big Crunch hypothesis. The universe can be expanding so long as it eventually collapses. Even in this case it's not correct to say that the universe is a black hole. The spacetime geometry is very different. A black hole, as I've posted elsewhere in this thread, is a region from which light can't escape to infinity. But in a universe that will end up in a Big Crunch, there is no infinity: space has a finite volume (which increases up to maximum expansion and then decreases back to zero).
- OscarCunningham 10y agoThen can any black hole exist in such a universe?
- pdonis 10y agoIn a closed universe that collapses to a Big Crunch, no, no black holes can exist. Everything will eventually come back together at the crunch.
- stouset 10y agoThat's actually a super-interesting result. It would be totally plausible to have supermassive black holes inside of universe-sized black holes. Neat.
- lloeki 10y agoI'm not sure because the above result doesn't say anything about the distribution of such mass, and intuitively since the light cone tips over once you're past the event horizon, everything inside is converging towards the singularity following a law that may prevent any black hole inside black hole from existing (but that's way over my head now).
- trhway 10y ago>everything inside is converging towards the singularity singularities are result of the pure abstract model of [mathematically] continuous spacetime. In real live at small scales the continuity gets broken and as one of the results of it we have QM - if you think about a typical large, star sized, black hole than you can see how degenerate matter in the center would provide the opposite pressure against collapse into singularity similarly like it happens in neutron star. The difference here is that in neutron star the limited existing mass of the star limits the resulting neutron degeneracy level achieved. In case of a black hole the process doesn't stop and as more and more mass comes in the degeneracy goes further/higher with the neutrons being pushed into even higher energy levels and starting to be teared apart into separate quarks and gluons, and as even more mass/energy comes in the quarks get teared apart even further one from another with the new pairs of quarks appearing as a result... That would provide the pressure opposing collapse into singularity. The more incoming gravitational mass/energy pressure the stronger the response. Btw, that boiling quark-gluon soup looks suspiciously like something that is hypothesized as what was in the beginning of our Universe ( what could have triggered the Big Bang explosion/expansion? - may be merge with another super-hyper-gigantic black hole).
- pdonis 10y ago> In real live at small scales the continuity gets broken This is a common speculation in quantum gravity, but at this point that's all it is: a speculation. We have no evidence that spacetime is not continuous. And given the predicted scale at which continuity would break down if the quantum gravity speculations are correct (about twenty orders of magnitude smaller than the smallest scale we can currently probe), we aren't likely to be able to test those speculations any time soon.
- gigatexal 10y agoWhoa so there's a possible that the visible universe is a black hole?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pja 10y agoYes, absolutely - black holes don’t need singularities inside them in order to be black holes. Just enough mass in a small enough volume. (Of course, we don’t actually know whether stellar or galactic centre black holes have singularities inside them - we just don’t know of any process that will prevent one from forming in current physics.)
- BurningFrog 10y agoIf our universe is a very big black hole, that means light cannot leave it. So where does it go? My intuition - which is almost certainly wrong - says it would turn back around, and be visible as a faint background radiation.
- pdonis 10y ago> black holes don’t need singularities inside them in order to be black holes. They do according to the standard GR model. Speculations about holes not having singularities inside them are quantum gravity speculations and we have no way of testing them experimentally any time soon.
- pja 10y agoTrue! Hmm. I retract my statement: Penrose/Hawking predict that all GR black holes contain singularities. In our universe, it looks like inflation is the fly in that particular prediction: The universe is going to tear itself apart instead.
- pdonis 10y ago> In our universe, it looks like inflation is the fly in that particular prediction: The universe is going to tear itself apart instead. reply I assume you're referring to the "Big Rip" scenario? That's not considered very likely, at least according to our best current data.
- xgbi 10y agoWait, what? So admitedly, a few (bilion) years back, when the universe had a radius smaller than ~14B ly, it was sufficiently dense to be a black hole? I mean, what ? Our universe did not lose mass in between (if we admit that it is a "closed" system), so at some point in the past, it grew out of being a black hole when it expanded above its Schwartzschild radius?
- Retric 10y agoAs long as you have ~uniform density out to the edge of the observable universe you get zero net gravity. Move over 1 light year and that particle also sees ~uniform density out to the edge of it's observable universe and you don't get a vast black hole.
- pdonis 10y ago> a few (bilion) years back, when the universe had a radius smaller than ~14B ly, it was sufficiently dense to be a black hole? > at some point in the past, it grew out of being a black hole when it expanded above its Schwartzschild radius? No and no. The calculations of the "Schwarzschild radius" corresponding to a given mass assume that the mass is static. They do not apply to an expanding universe.
- k__ 10y ago> that number sounds strangely familiar, isn't it? I don't know much about universes. Why should this number sound familiar?
- casiotone 10y agoThe universe is roughly 13.8 billion years old.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoWhere do you get the 46B ly radius from?
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoNever mind, I figured it out. ("Size of the universe" on Wikipedia, if you're curious.)
- antognini 10y agoYes, the "density" of a typical supermassive black hole at the center of a galaxy is roughly the density of water.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- edem 10y agoI'm not following. Why is that number familiar? Can you explain this in layman's terms?
- somedumbguy22 10y agoIt's the current age of the universe.