5 ms·
> Particularly galling to U.S. officials is that the men worked for the cyber investigative arm of the FSB - a rough equivalent of the FBI's Cyber Division. Tha
by dmix 10y ago
> Particularly galling to U.S. officials is that the men worked for the cyber investigative arm of the FSB - a rough equivalent of the FBI's Cyber Division. That the agency that is supposed to investigate computer intrusions Russia is engaged in hacking is "pretty sad," one official said.
This is why the FBI not engaging in their own grey-area shady offensive cyber techniques is so important, if they plan on making statements like these and expect to be taken seriously. Even if the FBI always find ways to get away with it legally, it still doesn't help their case when claiming moral high ground.
There is nothing Russia loves better than to dismiss claims against them because the US does it too - and the Russian public eats this "US double standard" up every time. They just see what Russia does as more explicit. Without giving Russia this easy out I don't see how enforcement like this is going to be effective. They show no signs of slowing down. Unless some new sanctions are planned?
Finding legal avenues instead of hiring shady Russian criminal hackers might seem like a big difference but the end results are hard to distinguish.
Last week the FBI let a pedophile who ran a hugely popular darknet CP site go instead of revealing the full details of their own hacking: https://www.wired.com/2017/03/feds-rather-drop-child-porn-case-give-exploit/ https://www.wired.com/2017/03/feds-rather-drop-child-porn-ca...
Consistency really does matter...
- pjc50 10y agoIndeed. Many years ago a treaty was made against the militarisation of space - which has largely been kept. There was an opportunity some time back to try to regulate the use of ""cyberwarfare"" against civilians, but it wasn't taken. The US was quite happy to use it against other countries. Unfortunately, like biological weapons, these techniques don't go back in the box very easily. We're entering an era where economic and political sabotage by hostile intelligence agencies - in both directions, and occasionally between "allies" or even in the same country - is becoming increasingly common.
- zby 10y agoThe problem of attribution is much worse with cyberweapons than with anything that has to be delivered physically. That makes any treaty impossible to enforce.
- mtgx 10y agoIndeed. Pretty sad. https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/fbi-hacked-over-8000-computers-in-120-countries-based-on-one-warrant https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/fbi-hacked-over-8... > Consistency really does matter... It does. That's why the U.S. has stopped calling out China on its human rights abuses, for instance.
- vtange 10y agoIt should be noted that China also plays the "US double-standard" card, especially when it comes to human rights. They practically emulate Russia as well when it comes to cyberspace. What interests me is how the public is somehow more inclined to specifically confront Russia when both effectively undermine the effectiveness and legitimacy of liberal democracies.
- _nox_ 10y agoDouble standard "card"? I find it interesting, that every mention of a double standard here is to lament the fact that the US is being called out on it. Not the fact, that the US in engaging in it. When you do something questionable, and then try to shame others for doing the same, it is a double standard.
- abraves10001 10y ago> This is why the FBI not engaging in their own grey-area shady offensive cyber techniques is so important The original comment isn't exclusively lamenting the double standard, it is saying we shouldn't do it so the double standard can't be applied.
- ykler 10y agoI guess "hypocrisy" is a better term. The term "double standard" suggests an unfair discrepancy in how two cases are treated, especially when this discrepancy is concealed and especially if the concealment is so deep that the perpetrator is self-deceived (so subtle sexism in hiring is a better example than Jew quotas for university admission or different penalties for crack and powder cocaine). An important difference from hypocrisy is that, with a double standard, the group that is judging in an unfair way is typically itself not engaging in the behavior being judged. For instance, an interviewer might have a double standard for male and female job applicants who have a certain kind of black mark on their record (or a certain kind of mark of excellence for that matter), but the interviewer is not a job applicant at all, let alone one with this kind of black mark. Another difference is that with hypocrisy the underlying behavior being judged has to be something bad, and accusing an accuser of hypocrisy is no real defense. (However, hypocrites often profess exaggerated standards of morality, and the best solution may be for everyone to just moralize less on the particular thing they are on about, so accusing an accuser of hypocrisy can be at least part of a defense.)
- anigbrowl 10y agoThere is nothing Russia loves better than to dismiss claims against them because the US does it too Except maybe having an opponent that doesn't keep up. I agree the US should not run itself as an imperium, but to expect any country not to have an espionage program is absurd. Countries engage in espionage for the same reason that they have military forces - if they don't, someone will take advantage of the fact and they won't be able to do anything about it.
- nkassis 10y agoI think OP meant that the FBI itself shouldn't get into this business and leave it to the CIA and NSA. As far as I know there is no separation of those duties in Russia, it's all done by the FSB.
- baursak 10y agoWhat difference does it make? They all report to the same person, and in the eyes of Russians it's all Federal US Government regardless of what three-letter acronym is acting as a front.
- cpncrunch 10y ago>Last week the FBI let a pedophile who ran a hugely popular darknet CP site go instead of revealing the full details of their own hacking: You can't really compare hacking suspected pedophiles to hacking yahoo.
- superkuh 10y agoYou can though because the reason they don't want to go into the details is that it wasn't targeted hacking. You can't target individuals on privacy maintaining networks like tor, i2p, freenet, gnunet, etc. You have you hack very large groups of people indiscriminately. That's why the FBI made changes to their procedural rules at the start of this year saying they could hack anyone who obscures their point of origin. Now they can get a single warrant and hack millions of people with it and it's still "okay". To be clear: they weren't just hacking "suspected pedophiles". They were hacking a huge population of people then sorting through after. Just like an attack on yahoo.
- baursak 10y ago> There is nothing Russia loves better than to dismiss claims against them because the US does it too - and the Russian public eats this "US double standard" up every time. They just see what Russia does as more explicit. There's a new Russian term for this phenomenon. "Reverse cargo cult". https://www.reddit.com/r/bestof/comments/5rtznu/idioma_explains_a_reverse_cargo_cult_and_how_it/ https://www.reddit.com/r/bestof/comments/5rtznu/idioma_expla...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]