3 ms·
> Can the scientific method be trusted or not? The scientific method can be trusted, but how it is implemented can not. Science only considers something to be
by grecy 10y ago
> Can the scientific method be trusted or not?
The scientific method can be trusted, but how it is implemented can not.
Science only considers something to be "fact" or "true" when a large (and usually expensive) study has been conducted, the results have been peer reviewed, and the results are then published.
The problem comes when the people paying for research only pay for research they want to be "true" and nobody will pay for research leading to things that might not be so good for sales.
As an example - think about how much money it cost to do a study on this Monsanto chemical to find out if it's "safe". Monsanto are paying for the study - do you really think if that study finds out it's not safe that it will be peer reviewed and published and then considered "true" (that it's not safe). Or will the whole study be swept under the rug, and therefore never be found to be unsafe in the eyes of science?
How many multi-million dollar studies have ever been conducted, peer reviewed and published (therefore making them "true" in the eyes of science) that tell us really anything in today's world is "bad" for us? I'm willing to bet that number is close to zero. Any published study was paid for by a system with very, very strong interests in the results, so science will only ever "learn" what the people with money want it to.
- exabrial 10y agoGreat, so if I think there are a lot of companies (solar, wind, "sustainable materials", etc) that have a vested interest in trying to prove that global warming is a man made construct, then I'm just practicing good science?
- arca_vorago 10y ago"Science only considers something to be "fact" or "true" when a large (and usually expensive) study has been conducted, the results have been peer reviewed, and the results are then published." If it hasn't or can't be replicated by and independent entity it's not good science. Peer-reviewed is simply not a high enough bar to consider something fact.