3 ms·
> So a sign on an intersection can be rendered void/meaningless if the traffic light is operational. But that's a moot point if the light isn't there in the fi
by lisper 10y ago
> So a sign on an intersection can be rendered void/meaningless if the traffic light is operational.
But that's a moot point if the light isn't there in the first place.
I'm sorry, but no matter how you slice it, this light is stupid. What is needed is simply a pair of signs: STOP and RIGHT TURN ONLY.
- thomasmarcelis 10y agoIt is mandatory for there to be a light at the intersection by law
- lisper 10y agoYes, I get that. But it's a stupid law, and it should be changed. Traffic laws are not handed down by the gods.
- froh42 10y agoYes great idea. Build a new rule into a nation-wide law just to solve a problem that needs no solving as "red light with static green right arrow" is a typical sight over here in Germany and drivers DO understand it. It would be much better to change traffic la nation-wide so we can get rid of this ONE traffic light in Germany. Isn't it?
- iopq 10y agoYes, that light is costing tax payers every year to operate it. The law should be changed so that there is no need to do this.
- vidarh 10y agoHow much do you think it will cost to verify that such a legal change will not have unintended side effects?
- germanier 10y agoChanging the law and checking correct enforcement costs way more in people hours than the cost of operating a single traffic light. People underestimate the cost of regulation. Also, a consistent and simple set of rules should always be preferred and causes less human errors.
- dagss 10y agoChanging the law costs a lot, lot more you know..
- massysett 10y agoYes. It's stupid for a law to vest absolutely no discretion in the engineers so they may adapt to peculiar local situations.
- sksksk 10y agoThis light is an at intersection, the other three roads leading to the intersection have traffic lights too. If there is a power cut, then the other three roads will have no lights, drivers there will treat the intersection with one set of rules. Whereas the driver on this road with a sign will treat the intersection with another, potentially causing an accident.
- lisper 10y agoThere is no more possibility of an accident with a stop sign than with an always-red light because the rules for both are exactly the same: stop, and proceed only when there is no conflicting traffic.
- tici_88 10y ago"But that's a moot point if the light isn't there in the first place." When I said "traffic light" I meant the entire set of traffic lights of the intersection. You can't have just one lane without traffic light and all the others with. It would be highly confusing, also probably against the road laws. The point of the traffic light taking precedence over road sign is actually part of the rules of the road. It is also required knowledge for driver exams.
- lisper 10y ago> You can't have just one lane without traffic light and all the others with. Of course you can. > It would be highly confusing Why? > also probably against the road laws. Laws can be changed. The fact that "it's the law" is a stupid reason to keep doing something that doesn't otherwise make sense. Germans of all people should understand this. (And BTW, I am German.)